The Evolution Of Fragrant Flowers: Nature's Aromatic Wonder

Flowers are a key innovation in the history of complex organisms, dramatically altering the Earth's biota. They are the reproductive structures of angiosperms, which are flowering plants. Angiosperms are distinguished from other seed-producing plants by having flowers, fruits that completely envelop the seeds, and xylems consisting of vessel elements. They are by far the most diverse group of land plants, with 64 orders, 416 families, approximately 13,000 known genera, and 300,000 known species.

The evolution of flowers is closely linked to the evolution of their aroma. Floral fragrance is a key factor in attracting pollinators, which play a crucial role in the sexual reproduction of flowering plants. Pollinators are attracted to flowers by their colour and scent, and the evolution of floral fragrance is driven by natural selection.

The evolution of floral fragrance is influenced by both direct and indirect selection by pollinators and herbivores. Herbivores can impact the evolution of floral fragrance because floral traits mediate interactions with both mutualists and antagonists, resulting in patterns of conflicting selection. By reducing herbivore load with pesticide application, plants showed evolutionary changes in their floral fragrance within four generations. This finding suggests that the absence of herbivores relaxes the trade-offs between reproduction and defence, allowing for rapid evolutionary change in floral fragrance.

The evolution of floral fragrance is a complex process that is not yet fully understood. However, by studying the genes and genetic mechanisms involved, scientists are gaining a better understanding of how flowers evolved their remarkable diversity of forms, colours, and fragrances.

Floral fragrance evolved through pollinator-mediated selection when the physiological and ecological compromises imposed by herbivores were relaxed

The study by Ramos and Schiestl (2020) found that plants showed evolutionary changes in their floral fragrance within 4 generations when herbivore load was reduced with pesticide application, compared to plants with natural levels of herbivory. This finding suggests that the absence of herbivores relaxes the trade-offs between reproduction and defense, allowing for rapid evolutionary change of the floral fragrance, likely due to pollinator-mediated selection.

The study also found that the natural pollinator community was dominated by bees, and bees have been shown to impose positive directional selection on fragrance. The ability of bees to detect aromatic floral volatiles suggests that the evolutionary changes observed could be explained by positive selection by pollinators together with a relaxation of herbivore-induced trade-offs.

In conclusion, the study demonstrates that floral fragrance can exhibit rapid evolution likely through pollinator-mediated selection when the physiological and ecological compromises imposed by herbivores are relaxed.

Floral fragrance is expected to evolve under direct and indirect selection by both pollinators and herbivores

The evolution of floral fragrance is influenced by both pollinators and herbivores. Pollinators can impose selection on certain floral volatile compounds, and studies have shown that bees can detect and prefer certain floral scents. On the other hand, herbivores can have a role in the evolution of fragrance because floral traits not only mediate interactions with mutualists but also with antagonists, provoking patterns of conflicting selection.

The evolution of floral fragrance is complex and influenced by various factors, including the interaction of pollinators and herbivores, physiological cross-talk and genetic linkage between reproduction and defense-related traits, and the availability of pollinators and herbivores.

Floral fragrance fulfils the basic requirements for evolution driven by natural selection

Floral fragrance is expected to evolve under direct and indirect selection by both pollinators and herbivores. However, disentangling their relative contribution, and quantifying the evolutionary outcomes of their isolated and combined effects has remained challenging.

Using fast-cycling Brassica rapa plants and manipulating hand/bee pollination by Bombus terrestris and herbivory by Pieris brassicae caterpillars, researchers showed that plants under bee pollination and herbivory evolved reduced floral fragrance and lower pollinator attraction compared to plants that evolved under bee pollination only. This suggests that adaptation to pollinators was constrained by a resource allocation trade-off between reproduction and defence.

The collective evidence therefore suggests that the absence of herbivores relaxes the trade-offs between reproduction and defence and allows for rapid evolutionary change of the floral fragrance, likely due to pollinator-mediated selection.

The origin of the flower was a key innovation in the history of complex organisms, dramatically altering Earth's biota

The origin of flowers was a pivotal moment in the history of complex organisms, profoundly altering Earth's biota. Flowers, or angiosperms, are plants that bear fruits and seeds enclosed in a fruit. They are distinguished from other seed-producing plants by their unique reproductive organs, the presence of endosperm within their seeds, and fruits that envelop their seeds.

Angiosperms first appeared around 130 million years ago during the Cretaceous period, marking a relatively recent event in the geologic history of Earth. This emergence was followed by a rapid diversification of flowering plant species, establishing most of the flowering plant families known today. Angiosperms now outnumber ferns and cone-bearing trees, or conifers, by a ratio of 20 to 1.

The success of angiosperms can be attributed to their ability to enclose and protect their seeds, as well as their reproductive strategy. The flower, as the reproductive mechanism of angiosperms, played a crucial role in their proliferation. Flowers typically have both male and female reproductive parts, allowing for cross-fertilization and the masking of deleterious mutations in subsequent generations. This process, known as genetic complementation, enhances the fitness of offspring.

In addition to their reproductive advantages, angiosperms also benefited from their ability to adapt to various environments. They initially colonized areas of ecological disturbance, such as floodplains and volcanic regions, and quickly spread to new habitats. This adaptability, combined with their efficient reproductive strategies, contributed to the dominance of angiosperms in most ecosystems, replacing other seed-bearing plants.

The rise of angiosperms had far-reaching consequences. They became the primary source of nourishment for humans and other animals, playing a vital role in our existence. Moreover, their aesthetic appeal inspired artists, poets, and people from all walks of life. Angiosperms also played a significant role in the development of agriculture, providing us with plant-based foods and livestock feed.

The origin of flowers, with their complex reproductive mechanisms and diverse forms, marked a pivotal moment in the evolution of life on Earth. Their success and proliferation reshaped ecosystems and had a lasting impact on the planet's biota.

The ABC model of floral organ specification was developed by Elliott Meyerowitz and Enrico Coen

The ABC model is based on the idea that there are three distinct and overlapping regions, labelled A, B, and C, each spanning two neighbouring whorls. The identity of whorl 1 sepals is based on the A function, whorl 2 petals on a combination of A and B functions, whorl 3 stamens on a combination of B and C functions, and whorl 4 carpels on the C function.

The model also states that the B function domain is independent of the A or C function genes, and that there is an antagonistic interaction between A and C functions, resulting in the absence of C function activity in whorls 1 and 2, and A function activity in whorls 3 and 4.

The ABC model has been modified since its proposal, with the addition of the E function, resulting in the ABCDE model. The ABC model has also been modified to the (A)BC model, which proposes a new (A) function that first provides floral context by controlling floral meristem identity and subsequently regulates the B and C functions.

Frequently asked questions