Heidi Norton
Tide and Persil are two of the most popular laundry detergents on the market, with both brands offering fragrance-free options for those with sensitive skin. Tide's Free & Gentle liquid detergent is formulated without common irritants and is free of dyes, fragrances, and preservatives, making it a top choice for those with skin conditions like psoriasis and eczema. Persil also offers a fragrance-free detergent, although some reviewers note that it doesn't clean as well as the original formula. With both brands consistently ranking highly in independent tests for their cleaning ability, the choice between the two comes down to personal preference.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Product Form | Tide: Liquid or discs; Persil: Liquid or powder |
| Brand History | Tide: Launched in 1946; Persil: Launched in 1907, entered the US market in 2015 |
| Brand Owner | Tide: P&G; Persil: Henkel |
| Number of Scents | Tide: 6; Persil: 2 |
| Suitability for Sensitive Skin | Both offer fragrance-free options |
| Stain Removal | Tide: Excellent at removing grease and oil stains; Persil: Excellent at removing cocoa stains |
| Price | Tide: 20 cents per load; Persil: 22 cents per load |
| Dermatologist-Tested Formula | Tide: Yes; Persil: No |
| Awards | Tide: Earned awards and is the trusted brand for all 32 NFL teams; Persil: N/A |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Tide's fragrance-free detergent is better at removing stains than Persil's
- Persil's fragrance-free detergent is more readily available than Tide's
- Tide's scented detergent is preferred by customers over Persil's
- Persil's scented detergent is considered overpowering by some customers
- Persil's detergent is newer to the US market than Tide's
Tide's fragrance-free detergent is better at removing stains than Persil's
Tide and Persil are two of the most popular detergents on the market, with both brands offering detergents that contain no fragrance or dyes for those with sensitive skin. However, when it comes to fragrance-free detergents, Tide has the edge over Persil in terms of stain removal.
Tide Free & Gentle liquid detergent is formulated without common irritants and is free of dyes, fragrances, and the preservative MI/MIL. It has been recognised for its stain elimination power, particularly for grease and oil-based stains, and has been certified by the National Psoriasis Foundation and the National Eczema Association. In comparison, while Persil Original Liquid Detergent Everyday Clean performed very well on all kinds of stains, tackling tea, cocoa, and chocolate-based stains effectively, its fragrance-free counterpart did not clean quite as well.
Tide's fragrance-free detergent has been praised for its ability to tackle tough stains and odours without leaving behind any scent, making it ideal for those with sensitive skin or noses. On the other hand, some users have found that Persil's fragrance-free detergent doesn't quite live up to the original in terms of cleaning power. While it still performs well, it may not be as effective at removing stains as Tide's fragrance-free option.
Additionally, Tide has a range of other fragrance-free detergents, such as Tide Ultra Stain Release, that offer powerful stain-fighting capabilities. Tide's innovative cap design also makes it easier to measure the exact amount of detergent needed per load, ensuring efficient and effective stain removal.
Overall, while both Tide and Persil offer fragrance-free detergents, Tide's options seem to excel at stain removal, making them a better choice for those seeking powerful and gentle cleaning performance.
Fragrance Samples UK: Legit or a Scam?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Persil's fragrance-free detergent is more readily available than Tide's
Tide and Persil are two of the most popular laundry detergent brands on the market. Both brands offer a range of products, including those without fragrance or dyes, which are suitable for customers with sensitive skin. While Tide and Persil detergents are widely available, Persil's fragrance-free detergent is more accessible to consumers for several reasons.
Firstly, Persil's fragrance-free detergent is available on major online retailers like Amazon, where it can be conveniently purchased and delivered directly to customers' homes. This option is particularly advantageous for those who may not have easy access to physical stores or prefer the convenience of online shopping. On the other hand, some customers have reported difficulties finding the fragrance-free Tide detergent in grocery or big-box stores, and they may have to explore alternative retailers.
Secondly, Persil's fragrance-free detergent is specifically designed for individuals with sensitive skin, and this variant is widely available. This option is ideal for those who experience allergies or skin irritation from scented detergents. The Persil Free & Sensitive detergent is hypoallergenic, dye-free, and fragrance-free, providing a premium deep clean while being gentle on the skin.
Additionally, Persil's fragrance-free detergent is available in a concentrated formula, which offers more value for money. The concentrated liquid detergent requires only half the amount of regular detergent, resulting in a more economical and space-saving option. This feature not only saves customers money but also reduces the frequency of store visits for detergent replenishment.
While both Tide and Persil cater to customers seeking fragrance-free options, Persil's fragrance-free detergent stands out for its wide availability, online accessibility, and specialized formula for sensitive skin. These factors contribute to its convenience and popularity among consumers seeking an effective yet gentle laundry solution.
Cosrx Snail Mucin: Fragrance-Free Formula for Sensitive Skin
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Tide's scented detergent is preferred by customers over Persil's
Tide and Persil are two of the most popular detergents on the market, with both brands consistently ranking at the top of independent tests for their superior cleaning ability. However, when it comes to scented detergents, Tide has the edge over Persil in terms of customer preference.
Tide offers a wider range of scent options, with six different fragrances compared to Persil's two. This variety gives customers more choices to find a scent they enjoy. While most customers find the smell of both brands delightful, some have described Persil's scent as overpowering. In contrast, Tide's Ultra variant has been praised for its subtle smell, which is less likely to be overwhelming.
Tide's scented detergents are also known for their effectiveness in eliminating odours. This feature is particularly appealing to those who need to tackle particularly smelly loads of laundry, such as gym clothes. The combination of a pleasant fragrance and powerful odour-fighting capabilities makes Tide a preferred choice for customers seeking a scented detergent that delivers both on scent and cleaning performance.
Additionally, Tide's scented detergents have been recognised for their ability to maintain the freshness of their scent even after washing. While some detergents may lose their fragrance during the washing process, Tide's Ultra variant has been noted to leave a pleasant scent on laundry, enhancing the overall experience for customers who appreciate fragrant laundry.
While Persil also offers scented detergents, some customers have expressed mixed opinions about their effectiveness in eliminating odours. Some reviews mention that the scent of Persil's detergents, particularly the Oxi version, can be polarising, with a few people finding that it made their clothes smell unclean. On the other hand, Tide's scented detergents, such as the Ultra Stain Release, have received positive feedback for their ability to remove stains effectively while leaving a pleasant fragrance on laundry.
VG and Fragrance: The Perfect Mix?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Persil's scented detergent is considered overpowering by some customers
The Persil Intense Fresh scent has also received mixed reviews, with some customers loving the scent and others feeling that it made their clothes smell unclean. The Oxi version of Persil has been noted to have a similar effect, with one reviewer stating that it made their clothes smell like they were "dirty".
On the other hand, some customers have no issues with the scented Persil detergent. One customer with sensitive skin stated that they loved the scent and had no problems with it. Persil also offers a fragrance-free version of their detergent for those who are sensitive to fragrance or prefer an unscented option.
While some customers find the scent of Persil overpowering, others may prefer it for its strong fragrance that lingers on clothes. Ultimately, the preference for scented or fragrance-free detergent comes down to individual choice, and Persil caters to both preferences by offering scented and unscented options.
Lamis and Prime: Are These Fragrances Identical?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Persil's detergent is newer to the US market than Tide's
Tide and Persil are two of the most popular laundry detergents on the market. Tide is manufactured and marketed by Procter & Gamble (P&G) and was introduced in 1946. It is the highest-selling detergent brand in the world, with an estimated 14.3% of the global market. Tide has a variety of products, including powders and liquid detergents, and is known for its effective branding and dedication to innovation.
On the other hand, Persil is a German brand of laundry detergent manufactured and marketed by Henkel. It was introduced in 1907 and was the first commercially available laundry detergent that combined bleach with the detergent. Despite its early success in Europe, Persil only recently entered the US market in 2015. This late entry is due to various factors, including an exclusive import agreement with upscale German appliance manufacturer Miele, which was later replaced by Miele's own brand laundry products.
In 2007, Henkel announced a global relaunch of the Persil brand and packaging to mark its 100th anniversary. This included a redesign of its sub-brands, Le Chat, Dixan, and Wipp. In 2011, Persil was introduced to Mexico, and in 2015, Henkel finally brought its premium detergents, Persil ProClean, to the United States. This move was a significant step for the company, as they had to adapt their flagship global product to the specific needs and preferences of American consumers.
While both Tide and Persil offer effective cleaning power and pleasant fragrances, their differences lie in their product offerings and history in the US market. Tide, with its earlier introduction and strong branding, has become a household name in the United States, while Persil is still relatively new and working to establish itself in the highly competitive detergent market.
Enhancing Your Fragrance: Using a Fragrance Booster
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Tide Free & Gentle is better at removing stains, particularly grease- and oil-based stains, but Persil Original Liquid Detergent Everyday Clean came a very close second.
Both Tide and Persil offer detergents that are free of dyes and fragrances for those with sensitive skin. Tide Free & Gentle is formulated without common irritants and is a certified EPA Safer Choice product, carrying seals from the National Psoriasis Foundation and the National Eczema Association. Persil Sensitive Skin is also designed for those with sensitive skin.
Tide Free & Gentle has a stronger scent that lingers long after the clothes have dried. Persil Fragrance Free does not have a scent but some users have complained that their clothes smell like they are "dirty" after washing.
Persil Fragrance Free is more cost-effective at 22 cents per load (110 loads in an 82.5-ounce bottle) compared to Tide Free & Gentle at 20 cents per load (80 loads in a 115-ounce bottle).
