The Truth About Whale Vomit In Cologne

Is cologne made out of whale vomit? Well, not exactly. Some colognes and perfumes contain a substance called ambergris, which is produced in the intestines of sperm whales. While it is commonly referred to as whale vomit, it is actually more akin to fecal matter. Ambergris is formed when a sperm whale is unable to expel the indigestible beaks and other parts of its prey (usually squid) through vomiting, and these parts move into the whale's intestines, where they bind together with fatty secretions and other waste to form a solid mass. Over time, this mass is excreted – either passed or, in some theories, by rupturing the whale's rectum – and can eventually be found floating in the ocean or washed up on beaches.

What is ambergris?

Ambergris is a rare, waxy substance sometimes found in the digestive system of a sperm whale. It is commonly referred to as "whale vomit", although this is a misnomer as it is likely a type of fecal matter.

Sperm whales eat large quantities of squid, but they cannot digest their sharp beaks. These beaks usually get vomited out, but sometimes they make it into the whale's gut. As the beaks traverse the whale's intestines, the whale starts to produce ambergris. The beaks bind together with feces, forming a solid mass that obstructs the rectum. Eventually, the mass is released from the whale, either by being passed or by rupturing the whale's rectum, which is sometimes fatal.

When removed from the whale, ambergris has a strong fecal smell. However, as the waxy substance bobs in the sea and is exposed to the sun, it hardens, lightens in colour, and takes on a more pleasant, musky scent. This process can take years, and the longer the ambergris is exposed to the sea, the better the quality is thought to be.

For centuries, ambergris has been used as a fixative in high-end perfumes, helping to make their scents last longer. It is also valued for its own unique smell, which has been described as "a bouquet of 20-30 chemical compounds that each have their own odor profile". One compound may smell like tobacco, while another smells like grass and hay. These strong scents are used as base notes in perfumes, forming the foundation of the fragrance.

Due to its rarity and the high demand from perfumers, ambergris can be extremely valuable. It can sell for thousands or even millions of dollars, with a single gram costing more than silver. However, as it is sourced from sperm whales, an internationally threatened species, the trade of ambergris is banned in some countries, including the US. Today, synthetic alternatives are often used in perfumes instead.

Is it ethical to use ambergris?

Ambergris, sometimes referred to as "whale vomit", is a rare substance produced by sperm whales. It is a natural byproduct of their diet, formed in their intestines and excreted. It is highly valued in perfumery for its unique, long-lasting fragrance and ability to make perfumes last longer on the skin.

The ethics of using ambergris is a nuanced topic. On the one hand, acquiring ambergris is generally considered ethical since it is typically excreted from the whale naturally and does not involve direct harm to the animal. However, there are several factors that complicate this issue.

Firstly, sperm whales are an endangered species, and their populations have declined due to commercial whaling, habitat loss, and pollution. The trade of ambergris is regulated due to the protected status of sperm whales, and it is illegal to trade or possess it in some countries. This regulation aims to prevent any potential harm to the already vulnerable whale population.

Secondly, while ambergris is usually collected after it has been naturally excreted by the whale, there have been cases where it has been obtained from beached or dying whales. This practice is considered unethical and is often done in an uncontrolled manner, raising concerns about animal cruelty.

Thirdly, the illegal trade in ambergris can contribute to the demand for whale products and potentially lead to the accidental killing of whales. Some countries have banned its use to discourage the illegal trade in whale products and protect endangered species.

Finally, the secrecy surrounding the ambergris trade, particularly at the top levels involving large companies and middlemen, makes it difficult to ensure ethical sourcing.

To address these concerns, synthetic alternatives to ambergris, such as ambroxan, have become popular. These alternatives are more sustainable, ethical, and environmentally responsible, providing a consistent and controlled scent profile while avoiding any impact on whale populations.

In conclusion, while the use of naturally excreted ambergris may not directly harm whales, the broader ethical implications of the trade, including the endangerment of whales and potential animal cruelty, must be considered. The availability of synthetic alternatives also makes it possible to move away from the use of ambergris altogether, further reducing any potential negative impact on whale populations.

How is ambergris harvested?

Ambergris is a rare, natural byproduct of the sperm whale's squid-based diet. It is produced in the sperm whale's intestines and passed out of the body along with faecal matter.

There are conflicting opinions on how exactly ambergris emerges from the whale. Some believe that the whale regurgitates the mass, earning it its nickname 'whale vomit'. However, Richard Sabin, Principal Curator of Mammals at the Natural History Museum, believes that "ambergris forms in the intestines and passes along with faecal matter, forming an obstruction in the rectum". Some think the whale will pass the mass, while others believe the obstruction grows so large that it eventually fatally ruptures the whale's rectum.

Once expelled by a whale, ambergris often floats for years before making landfall. It is found primarily in the Atlantic Ocean and on the coasts of South Africa, Brazil, Madagascar, the East Indies, The Maldives, China, Japan, India, Australia, New Zealand, and the Molucca Islands. Most commercially collected ambergris comes from the Bahamas in the Atlantic, particularly New Providence.

The harvesting of ambergris does not harm the whales, and it is banned in the United States to avoid exploiting this endangered species.

Why is ambergris so valuable?

Ambergris, commonly known as "whale vomit", is a rare and valuable substance produced by sperm whales. It is formed in the whale's digestive system when it consumes squid, which has sharp beaks and pens that are usually indigestible and vomited out. In rare cases, these indigestible parts move into the intestines and bind together with other matter, forming a solid mass of ambergris that grows over time.

The value of ambergris lies in its use in perfumery and its intriguing scent. Ambrein, an odourless alcohol extracted from ambergris, is a fixative that helps extend the longevity of fragrances on the skin. It is highly sought after by perfumers due to its ability to make scents last longer and enhance their complexity.

Additionally, ambergris possesses a unique and alluring scent that develops over time. Initially, fresh ambergris has a strong faecal odour, but as it ages, it dries out and its scent becomes more pleasant and musky. The longer it is exposed to the sea, the higher its quality is believed to be. This ageing process results in a complex bouquet of 20-30 chemical compounds, each contributing to its distinctive fragrance.

The rarity of ambergris further contributes to its value. It is produced only by a small percentage of sperm whales, and even then, it is found in less than 5% of whale carcasses. Its scarcity drives up the price, with chunks of ambergris selling for thousands or even millions of dollars.

In summary, ambergris is valuable because of its ability to extend the longevity of fragrances, its intriguing and complex scent, and its extreme rarity. Its use in perfumery, along with its unique olfactory qualities and limited availability, make it a highly prized and sought-after commodity.

What does ambergris smell like?

Ambergris is a rare, natural byproduct of the sperm whale's squid-based diet. It is produced in the intestines of sperm whales to help them pass sharp objects such as squid beaks. It is excreted into the ocean and accumulates a musky scent over time.

When it is first produced, ambergris has a strong faecal smell. However, as it ages, the odour matures and develops into a pleasant, musky fragrance. The longer it is exposed to the sea, the better the quality. It is often described as having a woody, ambery, sweet-earthy, and musky-marine scent. It has also been likened to the smell of tobacco, old churches, and Brazil nuts.

In the past, ambergris was used as a fixative in perfumery, helping to enhance a fragrance's staying power. However, due to its scarcity and regulations protecting sperm whales, it is now rarely used and has been largely replaced by its synthetic equivalent, Ambroxan.

Frequently asked questions