Stetson Sierra: Still In Vogue Or A Relic?

Stetson Sierra is a men's cologne by Coty, launched in 1993. It is described as a bold, rugged, and masculine scent combining fresh green woods with top notes of citrus and sage. However, it seems that Stetson Sierra has been discontinued, and it is challenging to find it in stores or online. While some sellers offer it at high prices, it may not be worth the cost unless you have a strong emotional attachment to the fragrance.

Where to buy Stetson Sierra cologne

Stetson Sierra cologne is available from several online retailers, including Amazon, Kmart, and Walmart.

Amazon offers a range of Stetson colognes, including the Sierra 3.0 oz cologne spray for $300. The product is currently out of stock, but you can check for updates on the website.

Kmart offers the Coty Cologne Spray 1.5 oz for $22.48, with a discount of 45% on the original price.

Walmart also offers the Coty Cologne Spray 1.5 oz, but it is currently out of stock.

It is recommended to check the websites for the latest information on pricing and availability, as stock levels and prices may vary.

Notes and scent profile

The Stetson Sierra cologne is described as a spicy, lavender, and amber scent. Its top notes include green notes, caraway, aldehydes, juniper berries, basil, artemisia, and bergamot. The middle notes are pine tree needles, caraway, rose, geranium, jasmine, and carnation. The base notes are musk, leather, patchouli, cedar, oakmoss, and amber.

The cologne's scent has been likened to a ""fizzy pine tree", with a "subdued foresty opening" and a "sweetness" that creeps in later. The sweetness has been described as fruity, with hints of banana and wintergreen. The cologne also has a "sharpness" that develops over time, smelling somewhat like alcohol.

Overall, the scent is reminiscent of classic aftershaves, with a "clean, green, pine opening". It is considered "old school yet classic" and "definitely [not] cheap".

Vintage cologne

One popular vintage cologne is Stetson Sierra by Coty, which was launched in 1993 and has a fragrance described as aromatic and fougere. With top notes of green, caraway, aldehydes, juniper berries, basil, artemisia, and bergamot, it offers a fresh and vibrant aroma. The middle notes of pine tree needles, caraway, rose, geranium, jasmine, and carnation add a floral and herbal touch, while the base notes of musk, leather, patchouli, cedar, oakmoss, and amber provide a warm and smooth finish.

Another option for vintage cologne is to explore online marketplaces such as eBay and Amazon, which offer a wide range of discontinued and rare fragrances. These include colognes from well-known brands like Versace, Ralph Lauren, Givenchy, and John Varvatos. Some of these vintage colognes are new and sealed, while others are partially used or being sold as collectibles.

Additionally, there are specialty websites that curate vintage men's colognes, such as Quirky Finds, which offers a range of options from different brands and eras.

Similar colognes

If you're looking for a cologne similar to Stetson Sierra, you might want to try one of the following options, which users have noted have similar scent profiles:

• Canoe by Dana, which features notes of spicy, lavender, and amber.
• Preferred Stock by Coty, which also has notes of spicy, lavender, and amber.
• Aspen, a fresh scent with notes of balsam, fir, and juniper.
• Pino Silvestre, which one user described as "a little too weak, but comparable".
• Belcam's Polo knockoff, Classic Match.
• Ralph Lauren Safari for Men.
• Azzaro Azzaro pour Homme.
• Guy Laroche Drakkar Noir.
• Jovan Jovan Musk for Men.
• English Leather English Leather.
• Alfred Sung Sung Homme.
• Burberry London for Men.
• Giorgio Armani Acqua di Gio.
• Geoffrey Beene Grey Flannel.
• Guerlain Habit Rouge Eau de Toilette.
• Giorgio Beverly Hills Giorgio for Men.

Customer reviews

Positive Reviews:

“I was lucky enough to find a 2 oz splash bottle of this for $5 thrifting. It was an instant buy on sight alone. Thankfully, the aroma turned out to be a winner that harkens back to some of the best touchpoints of the 80s and early 90s. Clean, green, pine opening that reminds me of classic aftershaves like Mennen Skin Bracer.”

“Aldehydes, pine, cedar, and jasmine, with a subdued blast of carnations. Of the many scents I've had the chance to smell, this is, no bullshit, one of the more unique. The aldehydes and pine come together to bring you a clear picture of a lake in the middle of an evergreen forest; the cool breeze sweeping through the spruce.”

“I absolutely love Stetson Sierra and I think this wonderful fragrance should be in everyone's collection. I highly recommend!”

“If I said this smells like a fizzy pine tree would you understand? Because it does. It smells alive. It smells like it is in motion. It isn’t quiet reflection in a forest. It is running through the forest, branches whipping past you. It is unique and it’s too bad it has been discontinued, because it had something to it that was rare, a pulse.”

“Lovely powerful, woodsy, well-rounded, and masculine. I maintain this has the same quality as many of the high-priced "black" fragrances. Reminds me of what one would get if they wore Drakkar and Polo together.”

Negative Reviews:

“I have the splash cologne and I think it's weak and doesn't last long but it is very old so it may have turned. It's a classic, though.”

“This stuff starts with a great subdued foresty opening, but a sort of sharpness later develops which is very solventy...it smells (and burns) more like alcohol 5 minutes after application.” Gradually a sweetness creeps in which I didn't detect at first, but it's fruity and metallic. At this stage, I think of household cleaner...maybe this is the Pinesol aspect that people say they smell in a lot of foresty scents.”

“I wore it to a party. Big mistake as all the guys made fun of me. It's actually not that bad if you're of retirement age.”

Frequently asked questions