Dry Hopping: Bitterness Or Aroma?

Dry hopping is the process of adding hops to beer after fermentation has begun. It is a technique used to add a fresh hop aroma to the beer without adding bitterness. However, there is some debate as to whether dry hopping adds bitterness to the beer. Some brewers argue that dry hopping can increase the perceived bitterness of a beer, while others claim that it only adds aroma and no bitterness. The prevailing wisdom is that dry hopping is for aroma only and that any effects on flavour are a matter of perception, with smell influencing taste.

Dry hopping can add bitterness to beer

Firstly, it's important to understand the difference between bitterness and hop taste. Bitterness comes from the alpha acids in hops, while flavour and aroma come from volatile oils. Boiling is necessary to convert alpha acids into iso-alpha acids, which create bitterness. However, during the boiling process, volatile oils that contribute to flavour and aroma are lost, which is why brewers typically add flavour and aroma hops towards the end of the boil.

Dry hopping is the process of adding hops to beer after fermentation has begun. It is done to impart a fresh hop aroma and unique taste to the beer without adding bitterness. The lack of boiling means that the volatile oils in the hops are preserved, resulting in a more intense flavour that is desirable in hoppy beer styles like pale ales and IPAs.

However, there is conflicting evidence on whether dry hopping can increase bitterness. Some sources claim that dry hopping does not add bitterness to beer, as the alpha acids in hops are insoluble in cold water/wort/beer and require boiling to become soluble and contribute bitterness.

On the other hand, some studies have found that dry hopping can influence the bitterness of a beer. Humulinones, which are formed by the oxidation of alpha acids in hops, are more soluble than iso-alpha acids and can be introduced into beer at normal temperatures through dry hopping. Humulinones are about 66% as bitter as iso-alpha acids and can increase the bitterness of beers with low IBUs. Additionally, alpha acids can also dissolve into beer through dry hopping, although their bittering potential is only around 10% that of iso-alpha acids.

Furthermore, the starting IBU levels of a beer also play a role. In high IBU beers, the leaf material in hops can absorb and reduce the amount of iso-alpha acids, resulting in reduced bitterness. However, in low IBU beers, the humulinones and alpha acids can increase the bitterness.

In conclusion, while the traditional wisdom is that dry hopping only adds aroma and not bitterness, recent studies have shown that it can indeed influence bitterness levels, especially in beers with low IBUs. However, the effect of dry hopping on bitterness is complex and depends on various factors such as hop variety, temperature, and the starting IBU level of the beer.

Bitterness comes from alpha acids in hops

Hops have been used for hundreds of years to produce beer, and their role in creating bitterness is well-known. The alpha acids in hops are the primary source of bitterness in beer. These acids are found in the resin glands of the flowers of the hop plant and are known as humulones. They exist in three forms: humulon, cohumulone, and adhumulone. The amount of alpha acids in hops is indicated as a percentage of their total weight, with higher alpha acid content leading to increased bitterness.

To release their bitter potential, alpha acids must undergo isomerization, a process triggered by high temperatures during the boiling of hops. This transformation results in iso-alpha-acids, which are more soluble in water and significantly more bitter. The longer the boiling time, the greater the isomerization and the more pronounced the bitterness.

While dry hopping is traditionally associated with adding aroma to beer, some studies have suggested that it can also influence bitterness. This effect is attributed to the formation of humulinones, which are more soluble than iso-alpha-acids and are created through the oxidation of alpha acids in hops. Humulinones can be introduced into beer at normal temperatures via dry hopping, impacting the final bitterness levels. Additionally, alpha acids can also dissolve into beer through dry hopping, although their bittering potential is lower compared to iso-alpha-acids.

The relationship between dry hopping and bitterness is complex and depends on various factors, including the initial IBU levels of the beer. In general, beers with lower IBUs tend to become more bitter with dry hopping, while those with higher IBUs may experience a reduction in bitterness. The perception of bitterness can also be influenced by the "hoppy" aroma, as suggested by a study where the addition of hop aroma extract led to an increase in the perceived bitterness of beers across different IBU levels.

Boiling is necessary to convert alpha acids to iso-alpha acids

Dry hopping is a technique used by brewers to add flavour and aroma to beer. It involves adding hops to the beer after the wort has been cooled, usually during primary or secondary fermentation, or directly to a keg. The term originated with British brewers, who would add hops to a cask shortly before shipping it to the customer.

The hops used for dry hopping are typically considered "flavour" or "aroma" hops, with relatively low alpha acid ratings (around 6% or less). Common varieties include Cascade, Crystal, Willamette, East Kent Golding, Fuggle, Saaz, Hallertau, and Tettnanger.

While dry hopping can add a range of desirable qualities to beer, it does not add bitterness. Bitterness in beer comes from iso-alpha acids, which are formed when alpha acids in hops are exposed to heat during the wort boiling process. This isomerization is a chemical process that rearranges the molecular structure of the alpha acids, altering their chemical properties and reactions. The longer the alpha acids are boiled, the more they are converted into iso-alpha acids, and the more bitterness is created in the wort and beer.

The boiling process is necessary to convert alpha acids into iso-alpha acids because it provides the required heat and time for the isomerization reaction to occur. This conversion is both time and temperature-dependent. While hops added late in the boil may still release their aroma oils, a much smaller proportion of their alpha acids will become iso-alpha acids.

In summary, boiling is essential to convert alpha acids to iso-alpha acids, which are the principal source of bitterness in beer. The boiling time and temperature can be adjusted to control the amount of bitterness in the final product.

Dry hopping can add a unique taste character to beer

Firstly, hops contain alpha acids, which are responsible for bitterness in beer. While dry hopping doesn't involve boiling, which is necessary to convert alpha acids into iso-alpha acids that create bitterness, it can still extract these acids from hops. The alpha acids extracted through dry hopping are not isomerized, and thus their bittering effect is different from that of boiled hops.

Secondly, hops also contain humulinones, which are formed by the oxidation of alpha acids and are more soluble than iso-alpha-acids. Humulinones can be introduced into beer at normal temperatures via dry hopping, affecting the final bitterness levels. Beers with low starting IBU levels before dry hopping may become more bitter due to the presence of humulinones.

Additionally, dry hopping can increase the pH of beer, which also increases the perception of bitterness. However, the effect of dry hopping on bitterness is complex and depends on various factors, including the type of hops used, the amount of hops, and the timing of the addition.

While dry hopping can contribute to bitterness, it primarily enhances the aroma and flavour of the beer by preserving the volatile oils in hops, which are responsible for flavour and aroma. These oils boil out of the wort quickly, so adding hops towards the end of the boil or during fermentation helps maximise their presence in the final beer.

Hops contain oils that add flavour and aroma

The composition of these oils varies depending on the hops variety and other factors, but hydrocarbons typically make up the majority of the total oil content. The hop flower contains alpha acids, and when isomerized, these acids provide bitterness to the beer. However, when the compounds in these essential oils volatilize, they contribute to and sometimes dominate the aroma and flavour of the beer.

The type of hop used and the timing of its addition during the brewing process play a crucial role in the final product. Aroma hops, for example, are typically used late in the boil or during dry hopping to enhance the aroma and flavour without adding significant bitterness. Dry hopping is a technique where hops are added to the fermenter after the yeast has been added, allowing for maximum flavour and aroma extraction while preserving the volatile oils. While dry hopping can introduce bitterness, it is primarily used to enhance the aroma and flavour profile of the beer.

Frequently asked questions