Fragrance Ingredients: Hormone Disruptors Or Not?

Fragrances are a complex collection of chemicals, and while the fragrance industry is unregulated, allowing manufacturers to label their products with simply fragrance, some ingredients are known to be toxic and hormone-disrupting.

Parabens and phthalates are preservatives that help scents last longer, but their molecular structure mimics hormones like estrogen and testosterone in the body. This means they can interfere with the release of natural hormones or cause their overproduction. Octoxynols and nonoxynols are emulsifiers that improve product effectiveness, but they too can cause endocrine disruption. Synthetic musk compounds are designed to mimic the natural scent of musk, but they accumulate in the body and the environment, creating potential health risks. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) are emitted as gases from liquids and solids such as cleaning agents, perfumes, and paints, and can cause dizziness, nausea, and eye and throat irritation.

However, the dose makes the poison, and while fragrances are not well-regulated, they are also not completely devoid of safety measures. The IFRA, an independent body run and funded by the fragrance industry, regulates fragrance ingredients, restricting those that are known or suspected to be hormone disruptors, allergens, or carcinogens to very low concentrations or banning them altogether.

While fragrances likely contain toxic and hormone-disrupting chemicals, the quantity is too small to have a significantly deleterious effect on the human body.

Phthalates and parabens in fragrances can interfere with the release of natural hormones or cause excess production

Phthalates and parabens are commonly found in fragrances and have been linked to potential health risks, particularly in women and children. These chemicals are known as "endocrine disruptors", which means they can interfere with the body's hormones and have far-reaching effects.

Phthalates are synthetic chemicals used to make plastics flexible and add fragrance to products. They are found in a variety of household items, including toys, personal care products, and food packaging. Research has linked higher phthalate exposure to health issues such as type 2 diabetes, obesity, fertility problems, and developmental issues in children. In adults, phthalates have been associated with reproductive problems, thyroid conditions, and menopausal symptoms.

Parabens, on the other hand, are preservatives used to prolong the shelf life of foods, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals. They are easily absorbed by the human body and have been classified as endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs). Studies have shown that parabens can interfere with nuclear receptors for hormones like androgens, estrogens, and progesterone. This disruption of endocrine homeostasis can lead to a range of health issues.

The combined presence of phthalates and parabens in fragrances can, therefore, interfere with the release of natural hormones or cause excess production. The exact mechanisms and long-term effects are still being studied, but the potential risks are serious enough that some companies have started making fragrance-free or chemical-free products. Consumers are becoming more aware of these potential dangers and are being encouraged to opt for products labelled "phthalate-free" and "paraben-free".

Octoxynols and nonoxynols in fragrances can cause skin irritation, allergic reactions, and potential damage to the environment

Octoxynols and nonoxynols are emulsifiers found in fragrances. They help dissolve substances that are not easily mixable, like oil and water, to improve a product's effectiveness. While octoxynols and nonoxynols are useful in improving a product's effectiveness, they have been associated with several adverse effects.

Octoxynols and nonoxynols can cause skin irritation and allergic reactions. These compounds have also been linked to potential damage to the environment. They are ethoxylated ingredients that can leave behind harmful chemicals such as 1,4-dioxane and ethylene oxide. These chemicals are associated with endocrine disruption, reproductive and developmental issues, cancer, and DNA damage.

The effects of octoxynols and nonoxynols on the environment are particularly concerning. These compounds are resistant to removal from the environment and do not easily break down over time. They can contaminate natural water sources and reach areas with minimal human contact through water systems and ocean currents. This contamination can harm animals and ecosystems, leading to fertility loss, species depopulation, and an increased risk of non-viable offspring.

Overall, while octoxynols and nonoxynols enhance the effectiveness of fragrances, they also pose risks to human health and the environment. It is essential to be aware of these risks and consider using alternative products that do not contain these compounds.

Synthetic musk compounds in fragrances can accumulate in the body and environment, and create endocrine disruption, carcinogenic effects, and allergic reactions

Synthetic musk compounds are used as a substitute for natural musk compounds extracted from animal glands. Natural musk is currently very expensive due to strict regulations on harvesting, so synthetic musks are used in most products to reduce production costs and increase profit. Most animal musk compounds are macrocyclic ketones, meaning they are a single large carbon ring containing double-bonded oxygen. Synthetic musk compounds are chemicals designed to mimic the natural scent of musk. They are rarely listed on the label, since fragrance ingredients are often not disclosed.

Synthetic musks are classified into three groups: polycyclic musks, nitro musks, and macrocyclic musks. The most common types of musks used in consumer products are nitro-musks (e.g., musk ketone and musk xylene) and polycyclic musks (e.g., galaxolide and tonalide). Nitro musks include musk ambrette, musk moskene, and musk tibetene, but these chemicals have been banned from use in products that contain fragrance because of their adverse reactions (e.g., allergic reactions) in humans.

Synthetic musks have been found to bioaccumulate in the environment and have been detected in human breast milk, body fat, blood, and umbilical cords. They enter the human body through skin absorption, inhalation, and ingestion of foods such as fish that are exposed to these chemicals. They are also detected in household dust and barbershop air. Due to their ubiquity and potential to accumulate, synthetic musks are pervasive in peoples’ bodies.

Studies have shown that these compounds can disrupt cell functioning and hormone systems. There is evidence that synthetic musks disrupt hormones.

Volatile organic compounds in fragrances can cause headaches, dizziness, nausea, difficulty concentrating, and irritation of the eyes, nose, and throat

Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are commonly found in fragrances. VOCs are highly volatile substances with low boiling points, meaning they vaporise at room temperature and can be easily inhaled. While VOCs are often naturally occurring, they can still have negative health effects, especially when used in high concentrations or over long periods.

VOCs in fragrances can cause a range of mild to serious health issues. Short-term exposure to high levels of VOCs has been linked to irritation of the eyes, nose, and throat, as well as headaches, dizziness, and nausea.

Fragrances can contain phytoestrogens, which are naturally occurring substances with hormone-like activity

Phytoestrogens have structures that are very similar to endogenous estradiol, a form of estrogen the body produces. They are also antioxidants and are anti-inflammatory.

The most well-studied phytoestrogen is isoflavone, which is found in soybeans and other legumes. The amount of isoflavones needed to have a health effect is around 40-70 mg/day, or an average of 50 mg/day. The average consumption of isoflavones in Asia is 15-50 mg per day, while in Western countries it is only about 2 mg per day.

Phytoestrogens have different effects on the body. They can reduce menopause symptoms, lower the risk of osteoporosis, reduce the risk of cancer, improve cancer treatment, and have a positive influence on cognitive function. They can also suppress the immune system and have feminizing effects in males.

Frequently asked questions