Fragrance Oils: Cancer Risk Or Safe Scent?

The use of fragrant products such as perfumes, air fresheners, and cosmetics is a common part of many people's daily routines. However, concerns have been raised about the potential health risks associated with these products, particularly regarding their possible link to cancer. The complex mixture of ingredients in perfumes, including synthetic compounds and natural compounds, has sparked debates about their safety. While some ingredients are well-studied and deemed safe, others have been flagged as potential carcinogens or endocrine disruptors.

The topic of fragrance and cancer is complex and multifaceted, with regulatory oversight varying across regions. The potential health impact of these products is an ongoing area of research and public interest.

The presence of phthalates, synthetic musks, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)

Fragrance oils have been found to contain a host of unlisted chemicals, with most coming from the scents used to boost their allure. Many of these chemicals are linked to cancer, birth defects, endocrine disruption and other health conditions.

Phthalates are a group of chemicals most commonly used in the manufacturing of plastics to make them more flexible and durable. They can also be found in pharmaceuticals, building materials, cleaning products, and other household goods. In fragrance oils, the most common type of phthalate is diethyl phthalate (DEP), which is used as a solvent to dissolve raw materials and increase the hot throw of a fragrance in soy wax. While phthalates have been linked to increased risks of breast cancer and fertility issues, they are still widely used in the fragrance industry due to their effectiveness and low cost.

Synthetic musks are also commonly found in fragrance oils. These chemicals have a warm, sweet, and powdery scent and are often used to balance and harmonize a fragrance formula. While some types of synthetic musks have been banned due to their neuro- and phototoxicity, as well as their poor biodegradability, others are still in use. Polycyclic musks (PCMs), for example, are highly stable and persistent, and have been found in human fat and milk. Although the damage from PCMs has yet to be proven, their presence in the human body is concerning.

PAHs are toxic contaminants that may be harmful to living creatures. They have been classified as priority substances by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and the European Union (EU) due to their mutagenic, carcinogenic, and teratogenic properties. PAHs are commonly found in mineral oils, and their presence can cause serious harm to the ecological environment and human health if discharged directly. While PAHs in fragrance oils have not been specifically studied, their presence in other types of oils raises concerns about their potential impact on human health.

The lack of ingredient disclosure on product labels

In the United States, the fragrance industry is largely self-regulated, and federal laws do not require the disclosure of specific fragrance components on product labels. The Fair Packaging and Labeling Act allows manufacturers to protect trade secrets, enabling them to simply list fragrance ingredients as "fragrance" without specifying the individual chemicals used. While this may be convenient for companies wishing to protect their proprietary blends, it leaves consumers in the dark about the exact substances they are being exposed to.

This lack of transparency is particularly concerning given that fragrances can contain a multitude of chemicals, with some blends comprising dozens or even hundreds of different ingredients. Many of these chemicals have been linked to serious health issues, including cancer, birth defects, endocrine disruption, allergies, and respiratory problems. For example, a study by the Breast Cancer Prevention Partners found a host of unlisted chemicals in commonly used products, with more than three-quarters of the chemicals of concern coming from the fragrance component.

The absence of detailed ingredient disclosure makes it difficult for consumers to make informed choices about the products they purchase and use. This is especially true for individuals with allergies or sensitivities to specific chemicals. Without full ingredient disclosure, it is challenging for consumers to identify and avoid products that may contain potentially harmful substances.

Furthermore, the lack of transparency in fragrance labelling can disproportionately impact certain vulnerable populations, such as children, women of colour, custodians, domestic workers, and cosmetologists. These individuals may be highly exposed to fragrance chemicals due to the nature of their work or the products they use, yet they lack the information needed to make informed decisions about their health and safety.

To address these concerns, there have been growing calls for mandatory ingredient disclosure on product labels. Some companies have voluntarily started disclosing all their ingredients on product labels or online, but a standardised approach is needed to ensure consistent and comprehensive information across the industry. Additionally, national legislation mandating ingredient disclosure has been proposed, such as the Safe Cosmetics and Personal Care Products Act of 2018, which calls for listing all ingredients, including fragrances, on packaging.

In conclusion, the lack of ingredient disclosure on fragrance oil product labels is a significant issue that warrants attention. Consumers have a right to know what chemicals they are being exposed to, and companies have a responsibility to provide transparent and detailed information about their products. By improving ingredient disclosure, consumers will be better equipped to make informed choices, avoid potential health risks, and advocate for safer alternatives.

The potential for endocrine disruption

The endocrine system is a network of glands that produce hormones, regulating various functions like growth, metabolism, and reproduction. Endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) interfere with this system, leading to hormonal imbalances and health issues. Commercial fragrances and perfumes often contain EDCs, which can enter our bodies through the skin or respiratory tract.

EDCs can alter hormonal regulation, potentially causing reproductive issues, thyroid dysfunction, and other problems. They can interfere with hormone creation and removal, signalling, and transport.

Common products containing EDCs include cosmetics (lipsticks, mascaras, foundations), sunscreens, plastic containers, cleaning products, air fresheners, candles, and laundry detergents.

Some specific EDCs found in fragranced products include:

• Phthalates: Found in perfumes, plastic bottles, and cleaning products. Interfere with thyroid and androgen receptors and are linked to cancer and birth defects.
• Parabens: Used as preservatives in cosmetics and lotions. Act as artificial estrogens and mild androgen/thyroid blockers, with possible links to breast cancer.
• Alkylphenols: Used as surfactants in soaps, shampoos, and toothpaste. Longer-chain varieties like nonylphenol have estrogenic activity and possible antiandrogenic effects.
• Synthetic musks: Used as a substitute for natural musk. Act as endocrine disruptors and possible carcinogens.
• UV filters: Found in sunscreens and cosmetics. Inorganic filters are suspected endocrine disruptors, while organic filters have shown stronger endocrine-disrupting effects.
• Triclosan: An antibacterial agent in cleaning products. A weak endocrine disruptor with effects on estrogen, androgen, and thyroid receptors.
• Cyclic methylsiloxanes: Used in hair products and skin care. May activate estrogen receptors and block androgen receptors.

The use of fragrance and parfum as generic terms to mask specific ingredients

The use of generic terms like "fragrance" and "parfum" on product labels is a common practice in the beauty, cleaning, and home care industries. These terms often cover dozens, if not hundreds, of chemicals, many of which have been linked to adverse health effects.

The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) estimates that perfumers have a palette of approximately 4,000 fragrance ingredients to choose from when creating scents for personal care products, cosmetics, cleaning products, and fine fragrances. However, the specific ingredients used in these products are often not disclosed, making it difficult for consumers to know what they are exposing themselves to.

In a 2018 report by the Breast Cancer Prevention Partners, a total of 338 fragrance chemicals were found in 25 personal care products tested, with 99 of those chemicals linked to at least one health concern. Fragrance chemicals accounted for three-quarters of the chemicals detected with links to chronic health effects.

The lack of transparency around fragrance ingredients is due in part to the protection of trade secrets. Fragrance formulas are considered proprietary information, and companies are not required by law to disclose all ingredients. This makes it challenging for consumers to make informed choices about the products they use and can be particularly concerning for individuals with allergies or sensitivities to specific ingredients.

To address this issue, some companies have started voluntarily disclosing their fragrance ingredients, and there have been legislative efforts to mandate the listing of fragrance substances. For example, the Safe Cosmetics and Personal Care Products Act of 2018 in the US calls for listing all ingredients, including fragrances, on packaging.

In the EU, a mandatory listing of 26 recognized fragrance allergens has been enforced since 2005, with specific labeling requirements depending on the intended use of the product.

The use of generic terms like "fragrance" and "parfum" allows companies to mask specific ingredients and preserve their trade secrets. However, this lack of transparency can make it difficult for consumers to make informed choices and may pose health risks, especially for vulnerable individuals.

Regulatory oversight and safety assessments of perfume ingredients

International Fragrance Association (IFRA) Standards:

The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) is a global trade organization that plays a pivotal role in establishing guidelines for the safe use of fragrances. Founded in 1973, IFRA collaborates with fragrance houses, regulatory authorities, and scientific experts to develop and update standards that promote the safe and sustainable use of fragrances. The IFRA standards cover various aspects, including the composition of fragrance ingredients, maximum concentration levels in consumer products, and labeling requirements. Adherence to these standards demonstrates a commitment to producing safe and high-quality products that meet consumer needs and expectations.

European Regulatory Requirements:

Fragrance manufacturers operating in Europe must comply with the regulations set by the European Union (EU). This includes the Registration, Evaluation, Authorization, and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) framework, which governs the use and handling of chemicals in consumer products, including fragrances. Under REACH, fragrance ingredients undergo rigorous safety assessments to ensure they meet strict criteria for human health and environmental protection. Fragrance manufacturers are required to provide comprehensive safety data and adhere to labeling requirements to inform consumers of any potential risks.

United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA):

In the United States, the FDA regulates fragrance products that are intended to be applied to a person's body to make them more attractive or are used for therapeutic purposes. These include fragrances in cosmetics, shampoos, shower gels, shaving creams, and body lotions. The FDA requires these products to have a list of ingredients, with fragrance ingredients listed as "Fragrance" or "Flavor" due to trade secret protections. While the FDA does not have the same authority to mandate allergen labeling for cosmetics as for food, consumers concerned about fragrance sensitivities can choose fragrance-free products or contact the manufacturer directly.

National Regulations for Household Chemicals:

The addition of fragrances to household chemicals, such as disinfection products, detergents, and pesticides, is subject to compliance with corresponding national standards and policies. For example, in China, the use of fragrances in detergents is governed by the GB/T 22731-2017 Daily Used Fragrances standard, which categorizes household products and prescribes limits for the use of different types of fragrances. Similarly, household pesticides in China must comply with regulations on the management of household fragrances, with a limit on fragrance content not exceeding 1%.

In conclusion, regulatory oversight and safety assessments of perfume ingredients vary depending on the region and the intended use of the product. Adherence to these regulations is essential to protect consumer health, ensure product quality, and promote environmental sustainability in the fragrance industry.

Frequently asked questions