The Fragrance Effect: How Scents Can Transform Your Mood

The protection of fragrances through intellectual property rights is a complex issue. While fragrances are generally protected through trademarks, the question of whether a fragrance can be copyrighted is more contentious. In 2006, a Dutch court ruled that a perfume could be copyrighted, recognising it as an artistic expression. However, this decision is not universally accepted, with the French Supreme Court ruling that perfumes are not eligible for copyright protection. The difficulty in representing and defining fragrances makes it challenging to establish copyright, and there are concerns that monopolies could result from allowing copyright protection for fragrances.

Fragrance types: perfume, eau de parfum, eau de cologne, eau de toilette, and eau fraiche

Fragrances are available in a variety of types, including perfume, eau de parfum, eau de cologne, eau de toilette, and eau fraiche. The difference between these fragrance types is the concentration of fragrance oils in the product, which affects the product's price, longevity, and intensity.

Perfume, or parfum, has the highest concentration of fragrance oils, typically ranging from 20% to 30%. It is the most expensive type of fragrance and can last up to eight hours. People with sensitive skin may prefer perfumes as they contain less alcohol and are less likely to dry out the skin.

Eau de parfum (EDP) has a fragrance concentration of between 15% and 20%. It is less expensive than perfume and usually lasts for four to five hours. EDP is suitable for everyday wear and is one of the most common fragrance types.

Eau de toilette (EDT) contains a lower concentration of fragrance oils, ranging from 5% to 15%. It is cheaper than EDP and typically lasts for two to three hours. Eau de toilette is considered daywear by some, while eau de parfum is seen as more suitable for nightwear. The term "eau de toilette" comes from the French phrase "faire sa toilette," which means "getting ready."

Eau de cologne (EDC) has an even lower fragrance concentration, typically between 2% and 4%. It has a high alcohol content and is the most affordable type of fragrance. Eau de cologne usually lasts for about two hours and comes in larger bottles. Traditionally, eau de cologne used herb and citrus notes with minimal base notes.

Eau fraiche is similar to eau de cologne in terms of longevity, as it also lasts for up to two hours. However, it has an even lower fragrance concentration, typically between 1% and 3%. Eau fraiche contains minimal alcohol and is mostly made up of water, making it suitable for those with sensitive skin.

In addition to these five main types of fragrances, there are also other varieties such as mists and aftershaves. When choosing a fragrance, it is important to consider factors such as concentration, longevity, skin type, and personal preference.

Fragrance notes: citrus, fruity, woody, spicy, floral, and oriental

The world of fragrances is complex, with many different scent categories or "fragrance families". These families are used to group perfumes by their dominant scent notes, and there are four overarching olfactory families: floral, citrus, woody, and oriental/amber.

Citrus

Citrus fragrances are composed of bright and tart citrus notes like lemon, bergamot, and orange. They are usually light and refreshing, and are often used as top notes in perfume due to their quick evaporation. Citrus fragrances may also be used as a standalone scent for daytime or casual wear, or they can be blended with floral or woody notes to create a more complex composition.

Fruity

Fruity fragrances are composed of sweet and fruity notes like apple, pear, or blackberry. They are often quite light and don't last as long as other types of fragrances. Fruity fragrances can be made up of a single fruit note or blended with several different fruits. They are often used to evoke a feeling of summer and can be layered with lighter fragrances to make them last longer.

Woody

Woody fragrances are characterised by notes derived from wood materials such as trees, roots, resins, moss, and some leaves and grasses that hold earthy qualities. Wood notes tend to be rich, warm, and aromatic, often forming the base of a scent due to their weight. Woody fragrances are often combined with fresh notes such as floral or citrus to give the woody warmth an appealing scent. Woody fragrances tend to be opulent and incense-like, and they can be given a twist by adding fruity notes, florals, herbs, and spices.

Spicy

Spicy notes are often combined with woody notes to create a warm, comforting, and sophisticated scent. Spicy fragrances can be found in both men's and women's perfumes and are often described as musky or smoky.

Floral

The floral fragrance family is one of the most popular, particularly for women's fragrances. While floral scents are most common in women's fragrances, they can also be found in men's. The overall impression of a floral fragrance is like fresh-cut flowers, but fruits and spices also come into play in the subfamilies.

Oriental

Oriental fragrances are full, heady scents created with spices, resins, and herbs for an opulent, seductive, and exotic appeal. Oriental fragrances are heavy and sensual, and they can be made even more appealing by blending in fruity or woody notes.

Combining Fragrance Notes

The fragrance wheel, developed by expert perfumer Michael Edwards, is a useful tool for understanding how different scents can complement each other. The wheel represents conventional and dynamic fragrances and how humans perceive them. It helps to identify which scents will blend well and which will clash.

There are three techniques for pairing scents using the fragrance wheel:

• The neighbour fragrance technique: Choose your favourite fragrance subfamily and look at the scents on either side of it on the wheel. Side-by-side fragrance subfamilies almost always complement each other well.
• The opposite fragrance technique: Choose your favourite fragrance subfamily and then select the subfamily that appears directly across from it on the wheel. For example, soft oriental and citrus would pair well together.
• The triangle fragrance technique: Choose three fragrance subfamilies that form a triangle on the wheel. As these will complement each other, you can find a fragrance that contains all three notes.

These techniques can help you find your perfect fragrance combination.

Fragrance allergens: undisclosed ingredients that can cause allergic reactions

Fragrances are a mix of chemicals that give products their unique smell. While they can enhance our experiences, they can also cause harm to our health. Fragrance chemicals are often undisclosed, and manufacturers are not required to list them on product labels. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for consumers to identify and avoid potential allergens.

Fragrance allergens can cause various allergic reactions, including contact dermatitis, an itchy, red rash on the skin. Inhalation of fragrance allergens can affect the respiratory system, especially for people with asthma, allergic rhinitis, or viral respiratory infections. Symptoms of respiratory irritation may include shortness of breath, coughing, a runny or stuffy nose, and wheezing.

Other potential health effects of fragrance exposure include cutaneous, respiratory, and systemic problems such as headaches, asthma attacks, breathing difficulties, cardiovascular and neurological issues, and workplace distress. Fragrance chemicals can also trigger allergic reactions such as cutaneous and pulmonary hypersensitivity and potentially disrupt the endocrine-immune-neural axis.

To protect yourself from fragrance allergens, it is important to read the ingredient panel on product labels carefully and avoid products containing known allergens. However, this can be challenging due to the lack of transparency in fragrance ingredient disclosure.

The good news is that you don't have to wait until you experience an allergic reaction to identify your specific allergens. You can get tested through patch testing or other methods such as prick tests, intradermal tests, and allergy blood tests. Knowing your specific allergens can help you make more informed choices to protect your health.

Fragrance effects: positive effects on mood and confidence, and negative health effects like migraines and asthma

Fragrances can have both positive and negative effects on people. On the positive side, fragrances can be used to express personal style and enhance one's overall look and confidence. They can also be used to match the mood or occasion, with different scents suited for day or night, and various seasons.

On the negative side, fragrances can cause a range of health issues, especially for people with asthma, allergies, migraines, or chemical sensitivities. Fragrance chemicals, often undisclosed, are considered toxic and can cause sinus congestion, sore throat, coughing, headaches, dizziness, nausea, and more. They can also trigger various acute and chronic pathological conditions, including respiratory and cardiovascular problems, skin hypersensitivity, and neurological issues.

The effects of fragrances are highly individual and depend on a person's tastes, personality, and skin chemistry. What works for one person may not work for another, and it's important to be mindful of this when using fragrances, especially in shared spaces.

Fragrance regulation: industry standards, labelling requirements, and trade secrets

The fragrance industry is largely self-regulated, with safety standards set by the industry's own International Fragrance Association (IFRA) and its research arm, the Research Institute for Fragrance Materials (RIFM). This has led to a lack of transparency and potential conflicts of interest, with little regulatory oversight of the safety of fragrance ingredients.

Industry Standards

The safety of fragrance chemicals is not determined, monitored, or safeguarded by any governmental agency globally. The industry has been trusted to self-regulate and establish its own safety guidelines, which has resulted in a lack of transparency and potential conflicts of interest. The current system for fragrance safety is run entirely by the IFRA and RIFM, with the latter's expert panel operating in secret without public oversight.

There is no independent review of laboratory practices, and most basic science studies on fragrance ingredients are conducted by the manufacturers themselves, often kept confidential and not published in peer-reviewed scientific journals. This raises concerns about the potential manipulation of results to serve the interests of the manufacturer conducting the testing.

While the IFRA standards include a list of banned or restricted substances, there are no restrictions on many controversial fragrance ingredients, including known carcinogens and phthalates. Compliance with these standards is also voluntary, and there is little to no verification required from fragrance manufacturers.

Labelling Requirements

Fragrance labelling requirements can be complex and vary depending on the region and product category. In general, fragrance products that are applied to the body to enhance attractiveness, such as perfumes, colognes, and aftershaves, are considered cosmetics. These products must adhere to labelling regulations and list their ingredients individually. However, due to the complex nature of fragrance formulas, manufacturers are often allowed to simply list fragrance ingredients as "fragrance" or "flavor" to protect trade secrets.

In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates fragrances depending on their intended use. Fragrance products applied to the body for therapeutic uses, such as sleep aids and muscle pain relief, are regulated as drugs and must be approved by the FDA before distribution. On the other hand, cosmetic fragrance products are FDA-regulated but not FDA-approved, meaning they are not reviewed prior to distribution. However, the FDA retains jurisdiction over cosmetics and their manufacturers to ensure compliance with federal laws and regulations, including labelling requirements.

To avoid legal repercussions and product recalls, cosmetic manufacturers must ensure appropriate labelling for the safety of consumers. Labels must include mandatory statements such as the product name, manufacturer's information, volume, ingredient list, usage precautions, and batch numbers. Labels must also include warning statements to prevent potential health hazards associated with the product.

Trade Secrets

The fragrance industry has a long-held tradition of keeping trade secrets for fragrance formulas, often labelling products with the blanket term "fragrance" to protect these secrets. This practice has resulted in fragrance ingredients being exempted from ingredient listing requirements in existing or proposed regulations. However, with innovations in reverse engineering technology, replicating a list of ingredients found in a fragrance has become possible, calling into question the validity of trade secret protections.

In summary, the fragrance industry's self-regulation and lack of transparency in safety standards and labelling practices have raised concerns among consumers, scientists, and health care providers. Increased regulatory oversight and transparency are needed to ensure the safety of fragrance ingredients and protect public health interests.

Frequently asked questions