Amazon Colognes: Are They The Real Deal?

Are the colognes sold on Amazon real? This is a question that has been asked by many, with varying responses. Some people claim to have received fake cologne from Amazon, especially when purchased from third-party sellers, while others say they have received genuine products. It is suggested that to avoid receiving fake cologne, one should only purchase from Amazon directly and not third-party sellers. However, even Amazon directly may not be a guarantee against counterfeits.

Amazon's commingled inventory means you may not get the product you ordered

Amazon's commingled inventory system can have several benefits for the company and its customers, but it also poses certain risks. The system involves mixing products from different sellers in Amazon's warehouses, streamlining the logistics process and reducing the time and effort required to sort, label, and store individual sellers' items. This leads to faster shipping times as products can be sourced from the nearest fulfillment center, benefiting both Amazon and its customers. Commingled inventory also allows for more efficient use of storage space, reducing overall costs for Amazon, which can then be passed on to sellers and customers in the form of lower fees and shipping charges.

However, one of the biggest concerns for Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) sellers with commingled inventory is the risk of receiving and unwittingly selling counterfeit products. Since items from different sellers are mixed, customers could receive a fake product from a different seller than the one they purchased from. This can damage the reputation of sellers who have worked hard to build a reputable brand and maintain quality control over their products. If a customer receives a counterfeit product, they may leave a negative review or even file a complaint with Amazon, which could result in account suspensions or bans.

Another issue with commingled inventory is the difficulty in tracking inventory. As products from various sellers are mixed, it can be challenging to determine which seller's products are being sold and how much inventory is left. This can lead to overselling, resulting in canceled orders, negative reviews, and potential account suspensions.

Commingled inventory can also impact branding and marketing efforts. With products from different sellers mixed together, it becomes challenging to differentiate authentic products from counterfeits, making it difficult to build and maintain brand trust with customers.

To avoid the risks associated with commingled inventory, FBA sellers can consider enrolling in Amazon's Brand Registry Program or using manufacturer barcodes for better tracking and protection against counterfeit goods. Staying vigilant and proactive in ensuring inventory authenticity is vital for safeguarding one's business and maintaining customer trust.

Amazon's customer service is poor

Amazon has been criticized for its poor customer service, with some customers reporting issues with refunds, account security, and product authenticity.

One issue that has been highlighted is the difficulty in cancelling subscriptions, particularly for Amazon Prime. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) filed a complaint against Amazon, accusing the company of "years-long effort to enroll consumers into its Prime program without their consent while knowingly making it difficult for consumers to cancel their subscriptions." Amazon has denied these claims, stating that they make it "clear and simple for customers to both sign up for or cancel their Prime membership."

In addition to subscription issues, some customers have reported problems with receiving refunds for fraudulent or faulty products. This is particularly prevalent with beauty products, such as fragrances, where customers have reported receiving counterfeit items or products that do not match their descriptions. While Amazon does offer refunds in some cases, the process can be challenging, and customers often have to resort to disputing the charges with their banks.

Another concern is account security, with reports of Amazon accounts being hacked and the company failing to resolve the issue promptly. In one instance, a customer reported that their Prime account was hacked within minutes of getting a new Echo, and despite spending hours on the phone with customer service, the issue remained unresolved.

The poor customer service has also been noted by sellers on Amazon, who have experienced issues with the Customer Service by Amazon (CSBA) program. One seller reported a significant decrease in their feedback rating after using CSBA, as well as an increase in damage claims and negative feedback from customers. The seller also mentioned that Amazon rejected most appeals for negative feedback, even for issues that were not their fault.

Overall, while Amazon has been praised for its convenience and product selection, the company has faced criticism for its customer service, with both buyers and sellers reporting issues with refunds, account security, and subscription cancellations. These problems have led to frustration and negative experiences for many Amazon users.

Amazon's return policy for fragrances is unclear

Some customers have reported difficulties in returning fragrances to Amazon, with customer service representatives initially agreeing to a return, only to be overruled by a colleague or manager. In some cases, customers have been instructed to "dispose" of or "donate" the unwanted fragrance. However, other customers have successfully obtained refunds or replacements for fragrances, even without providing a reason for the return.

It is important to note that Amazon's policy on hazardous materials, which includes flammable liquids or gases, may impact the returnability of fragrances. Amazon's policy states that hazardous materials cannot be returned, and customers should contact the manufacturer directly for service, warranty, return, and refund information.

The variability in experiences highlights the unclear nature of Amazon's return policy for fragrances. Customers considering purchasing fragrances from Amazon should be aware of the potential challenges and inconsistencies in the return process.

Third-party sellers on Amazon may be untrustworthy

While Amazon tries to keep scams at bay and bans sellers exposed as fraudulent, third-party sellers on Amazon may be untrustworthy. Here are some reasons why:

Refurbished Items

You might receive an item that is refurbished without knowing it. A Reddit user bought a computer from an Amazon third-party seller and couldn't get Windows 10 to activate. It turned out that the Microsoft product key had already been used, and the item was sold that way.

Non-Delivery of Items

You might not receive your item at all. This is a classic scam, especially for items that seem too good to be true in terms of pricing. Scammers will create a tracking label to prevent Amazon from flagging them, but the item never gets shipped.

Charging for Non-Delivery

In the case of non-delivery, you might still get charged. You will then have to file a claim with Amazon to get your money back if the third-party seller is non-responsive.

Misleading Product Reviews

Product reviews may be pulled from the manufacturer's site and not the seller's. For instance, a YouTuber found that a scam pizza oven listed on Amazon had 4.5 stars out of 614 ratings. However, upon investigation, these reviews were actually from the oven's manufacturer's site and not for the oven sold by the Amazon seller.

Unwanted Emails and Offers

There is a possibility that you will receive unwanted emails and offers from the third-party seller in the future. Amazon offers resources to deal with phishing and related scams, but common sense and vigilance are essential.

Poor Quality and Counterfeit Products

Third-party sellers on Amazon may sell poor-quality or counterfeit products. A Wall Street Journal investigation found that more than half of the 4,152 items they studied were problematic, including unsafe, mislabeled, banned, or not what was promised.

Long Shipping Times

Long shipping times may indicate that the seller is shipping the product directly from a warehouse in China, which often results in a poor experience for the buyer.

Amazon's warehouses have poor temperature control

While there are no sources that directly state whether or not colognes from Amazon are real, there are many customer reviews that indicate that they have received fake fragrances from Amazon.

Another user stated that the 53-foot UPS and FedEx trailers are often left under the sun at loading docks for a few days before Amazon gets around to unloading them. Daytime temperatures inside these trailers can reach the upper 70s to low 80s.

According to Amazon's meltable inventory requirements, products in fulfillment centers must be able to withstand a minimum temperature of 50 degrees Fahrenheit and a maximum temperature of 100 degrees Fahrenheit during the product's shelf life without hurting its quality.

Due to the inconsistent and often extreme temperatures in Amazon's warehouses, temperature-sensitive products are not suitable for FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon).

Frequently asked questions