The Art Of Masking Fragrance: Enhancing Your Scent Experience

Masking fragrances are used to conceal unpleasant odours and create a neutral smell. They are commonly used in skincare products to cover up the scent of otherwise beneficial ingredients. For example, ingredients such as urea, sulfur/sulfa, and hydrolyzed collagen may have foul odours, but a masking fragrance can make these ingredients more pleasant to apply and wear. It's important to note that fragrance-free products may still contain masking fragrances to improve the user experience.

Masking fragrances are designed to conceal bad smells and create a neutral smell

Masking fragrances are also used to cover the smell of the base of a product, especially natural bases with protein and herbal extracts, which can have off-putting scents. The goal of a masking fragrance is to give the perception that a product is unscented. However, this does not mean that the product is fragrance-free, but rather smell-free.

It is important to note that products labelled as "fragrance-free" may still contain masking fragrances to improve the user experience. These products will not contain added scents like essential oils or fragrance oils, but they may contain a small percentage of masking fragrances. This is because truly unscented products can often smell unpleasant due to the natural odours of their ingredients.

In addition to skincare, masking fragrances are also used in household products. For example, citrus-fragranced household cleaners are believed to be more effective than unscented ones. Similarly, dandruff shampoos with a menthol medicinal smell are thought to be more effective at alleviating itch than unscented shampoos.

They are commonly used in skincare products

Masking fragrances are commonly used in skincare products. They are used to conceal the foul odours of certain ingredients and create a neutral smell. For example, ingredients such as urea, sulfur/sulfa, and hydrolyzed collagen, which are commonly used in skincare, may have an unpleasant odour to them. A masking fragrance can be used to make these ingredients more pleasant to apply and wear.

The purpose of a masking fragrance is not to add a new scent but to cover up the malodor of the product. They are designed to be 'odour neutral' when added to the base. Creating an effective masking fragrance involves testing various ingredients to see which ones cover the malodor without adding a new odour. This process requires a thorough understanding of the chemistry of the base. It is also important to test how the masking fragrance stands up over time and under different temperatures.

It is important to note that products labelled as "fragrance-free" may still contain a small percentage of masking fragrances to improve the user's experience. These products will not contain added scents like essential oils or fragrance oils. However, most products deliberately add scents to make the product more appealing.

The term "fragrance-free" is not regulated, and there is no official or legal meaning when it comes to cosmetic labelling. According to the Food & Drug Administration (FDA), "even some products labelled 'unscented' may contain fragrance ingredients. This is because the manufacturer may add just enough fragrance to mask the unpleasant smell of other ingredients, without giving the product a noticeable scent." Therefore, it can be challenging to find truly fragrance-free skincare products.

They are also used in household cleaning products

Consumers tend to associate certain scents with the functionality of a product. For instance, citrus-scented household cleaners are perceived to be more effective than unscented ones. Similarly, dandruff shampoos with a medicinal smell are thought to be more effective at alleviating itch than those without a scent. This perception of enhanced product functionality based on scent is deeply rooted in the primitive olfactory centre of the brain.

Household cleaning products often contain chemicals that have foul odours. For example, ammonium thioglycolate, which is used in permanent hair waving solutions, smells like rotten eggs. Quaternized nitrogen compounds, commonly found in hair conditioners, also have an unpleasant odour. Even some surfactants used to cleanse the skin and hair are unappealing to consumers without the addition of a masking fragrance.

Masking fragrances are added to household cleaning products to conceal bad smells and create a neutral scent. They are designed to be 'odour neutral' and do not add a new scent to the product. The goal is to give the perception that the product is unscented. Therefore, 'unscented' does not mean 'fragrance-free', but rather 'smell-free'.

It is important to note that products labelled as 'fragrance-free' may still contain a small percentage of masking fragrances to improve the user experience. These products will not contain added scents like floral extracts or vanilla, which some consumers may be sensitive to.

Products labelled 'fragrance-free' may still contain masking fragrances

Products Labelled "Fragrance-Free" May Still Contain Masking Fragrances

When you see a product labelled as "fragrance-free", it is tempting to assume that it contains no scented elements. However, this is not always the case. While a "fragrance-free" label means the product doesn't contain ingredients added solely to impart a scent, it doesn't mean that the product won't have a smell.

The Role of Masking Fragrances

Many of the ingredients used in skincare products, such as fatty acids, fatty oils, and surfactants, can produce an unpleasant scent. To counteract this, manufacturers often add "masking fragrances" or masking agents to neutralize these undesirable odours and bring the product's scent back to a neutral state. The goal of a masking fragrance is to give the perception that the product is unscented. Thus, "unscented" does not mean "fragrance-free", but rather "smell-free".

Label Requirements

Adding to the complexity, there are no regulations around the term "fragrance-free". The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) considers fragrance additives used as masking agents and present in insignificant levels as incidental ingredients, which do not need to be declared on the label. Furthermore, if a fragrance additive serves a purpose other than giving the product a scent, it can legally be included in a "fragrance-free" product. For example, rose oil has a scent but also has moisturizing properties. So, if rose oil is included in a skincare product for its moisturizing effects, the product can still be labelled as "fragrance-free", even though the rose oil might impart a faint smell.

Potential Health Concerns

The lack of transparency in labelling can be concerning, especially for individuals with fragrance allergies or sensitive skin. Fragrances are the cosmetic ingredients most likely to cause allergic contact dermatitis, accounting for 30-45% of allergic reactions in cosmetics. Even if a product is labelled as "fragrance-free", it may still contain masking fragrances that act as allergens, potentially triggering allergic reactions.

Recommendations

For those with skin conditions or sensitivities, choosing the right skincare products can be challenging. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) recommends that patients with allergic dermatitis or eczema opt for products labelled as "fragrance-free". However, due to potential mislabelling, it is crucial to check the ingredient list carefully. Look for terms such as "parfum", "perfume", "fragrance", "aroma", and "essential oils", which indicate the presence of added scents. Also, be aware that fragrances can sometimes be listed under less obvious names, such as "benzyl alcohol", citrus ingredients, "lavender", "eucalyptus", and "tea tree".

If you are uncertain about a product, performing a patch test is a safe way to gauge its impact on your skin. Consult a licensed dermatologist or skincare expert for personalized advice based on your skin's unique needs and sensitivities.

Masking fragrances are not the same as added scents

While masking fragrances and fragrances are chemically the same, they are used for different purposes. Fragrances are added to create a pleasant smell, whereas masking fragrances are used to conceal a bad odour and create a neutral smell.

Masking fragrances are commonly used in skincare products. Many skincare brands find certain ingredients worth including despite their scent. For example, urea, sulfur/sulfa, and hydrolyzed collagen may have a foul odour, but a masking fragrance is used to make these ingredients more pleasant to apply and wear.

However, masking fragrances do not simply add a scent on top of a foul odour. They are often a chemical combination that allows the foul odour to subside or appear neutral. The unpleasant smell may reappear, as is the case with many self-tanners. The longer you wear it, the more you may notice the scent.

The goal of a masking fragrance is for a product to appear unscented. Thus, "unscented" does not mean "fragrance-free", but rather "smell-free". Products labelled "fragrance-free" may still contain a very small percentage of masking fragrances to improve the user experience. However, they will not contain added scents like essential oils or fragrance oils.

On the other hand, most products deliberately add scents to offer additional benefits and make the product more appealing. For example, consumers believe that citrus-fragranced household cleaners work better than unscented cleansers. Dandruff shampoos with a menthol medicinal smell are thought to alleviate itch better than unscented shampoos. Fragrance can also be used to imply the presence of an ingredient, such as a product containing strawberry extract that is fragranced like strawberries.

Frequently asked questions