Seamus Hammond
In the game The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, players can embark on a secondary and optional quest called The Scent of Incense in Chapter 1. The quest revolves around Geralt's encounter with a scholar at the docks in Flotsam, who believes a local shopkeeper is selling incense that produces poisonous smoke. Geralt agrees to retrieve the incense recipe for the scholar, leading to a series of events. However, some players have reported a bug where the quest appears to be completed initially, but then fails after progressing past Chapter 1. This issue has sparked discussions and speculation among players, with some sharing their experiences and potential workarounds.
Explore related products
$18.95 $19.99
What You'll Learn
The quest is marked as failed after entering Loredo's territory
In the game "The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings", the quest "The Scent of Incense" can be marked as failed under certain conditions. The quest involves Geralt, a scholar, and an alchemist/shopkeeper. Geralt meets a suspicious-looking character, Vencel Pug, who claims to be a scholar and wants the recipe for a popular incense sold by the shopkeeper, Vilmos Bartok. Geralt can choose to retrieve the real recipe or accept a fake one. He then returns to Vencel with the formula, who wants to test its authenticity in a laboratory.
- If Geralt refuses to be blindfolded and led to the laboratory, the scholar will mark the lab's location on Geralt's map and wait for him there.
- If Geralt presents a fake formula, Vencel (or Pugg, as referred to in some sources) will order his men to attack, and Geralt will have to kill the guards and the scholar. This may be due to a bug in the game, as it is suggested that Geralt should be able to leave after receiving the reward from the alchemist.
- If Geralt takes Roche's side after the big boss fight and enters Loredo's territory, the quest is marked as failed. This may be a bug, as one player suggests in the comments.
To avoid the quest being marked as failed, players suggest helping the Squirrels or ensuring that you have earned the proper, real formula for the incense.
Incense Charcoal: Toxic Fumes or Safe Scents?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The player refuses to give the recipe to the scholar
In the game The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, Geralt meets a scholar at the docks in Flotsam who wants to obtain a formula for an incense sold by a local shopkeeper. The player, as Geralt, can then attempt to get the recipe for the scholar. If the player refuses to give the recipe to the scholar, the scholar says "We'll meet again". The scholar and his henchmen then attack the player in the forest. The player can kill the scholar and the thugs, and the quest will be marked as complete. However, if the player later takes Roche's side and enters Loredo's territory, the quest will be marked as "failed".
It is unclear why the quest is marked as "failed" after the player takes Roche's side. Some players have suggested that this may be a bug in the game. In addition, some players have reported a ghost of the scholar appearing on the spot of the ambush, standing and swinging his sword. This ghost is non-interactive and may also be a bug.
It is worth noting that the player can choose to give the scholar the recipe, in which case the scholar will want to test its authenticity in his laboratory. The player can agree to be blindfolded and led to the laboratory, or they can demand to know the location of the laboratory and bring the recipe there. If the player chooses to be blindfolded, they will walk into a trap, but as a professional, Geralt can deal with the employer and the others.
Incense Cones: Do They Burn Down Completely?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The scholar's identity is unknown
The identity of the scholar in the "Scent of Incense" quest in The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings remains a mystery, even after the quest is completed. Players have speculated about the scholar's true identity and motives, but no definitive information is provided in the game.
During the quest, Geralt meets the scholar at the harbour, and the scholar claims that a local shopkeeper is selling incense that produces poisonous smoke. Geralt agrees to retrieve the recipe for the incense from the shopkeeper, but he later changes his mind and refuses to give it to the scholar. The scholar responds menacingly, suggesting that they will meet again. Indeed, Geralt does meet the scholar again, along with an alchemist and some henchmen, and ends up killing them in self-defence.
Despite completing the quest, players are left with unanswered questions about the scholar's identity and true intentions. Some players have reported encountering a ghost-like figure of the scholar after completing the quest, suggesting that the scholar's story may not be completely resolved. The scholar's unknown identity adds an air of mystery to the quest and leaves players wondering about the true nature of the character they encountered.
It is speculated that the scholar may be associated with an organisation called Salamandra, which has crossed paths with Geralt in the past. However, even after defeating the scholar and his associates, Geralt is none the wiser about their true identities or motives. The scholar's identity remains a secret, leaving players to wonder about the true nature of the threat they faced.
Burning Dried Jasmine Flowers: A Natural Incense Option?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The player receives a phony formula
In the game The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, Geralt meets a scholar, Vencel Pugg, who wants to obtain a formula for an incense sold by a local shopkeeper. Geralt agrees to get the recipe for him and sets off to find the incense shop. The player, as Geralt, then has several options: they can either convince the shopkeeper to give them the real formula, or accept a close substitute.
If the player accepts the phony formula, they will not receive a reward for completing the side quest. When Geralt returns to Vencel, he will want to check the formula in his laboratory before paying Geralt. The player can then choose to agree to this or not. If the player refuses, Vencel will respond menacingly, saying "we will meet again". The player can then choose to meet the scholar and his henchmen in the forest, where they will have to fight them. After killing them, the quest will be marked as complete, but the scholar's identity will remain unknown.
Incense and Air Travel: What You Need to Know
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The player is unable to find their weapons
In The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, players can undertake a secondary and optional quest in Chapter I called "The Scent of Incense." The quest is triggered when Geralt meets Vencel Pugg, a scholar seeking a formula for incense sold by a local shopkeeper. While the quest offers various paths and outcomes, players have reported issues with losing their weapons, particularly after choosing certain options.
One scenario where players might encounter weapon-related problems is when they agree to be blindfolded and led to the scholar's laboratory. After dealing with the enemies inside, some players have reported an inability to locate their weapons, even in previous saves. This issue might be due to a bug in the game, and reloading earlier saves does not always resolve it.
In another scenario, players who lie to Vencel Pugg and are subsequently locked in the cellar can break down the door, grab their weapons, and equip them. However, some players have reported that they are unable to use their weapons and can only fight with their hands. This issue might also be a bug in the game.
To mitigate these issues, players can try equipping a sword from a nearby rack instead of accessing their weapons from the chest. They can then return to pick up their regular weapons afterward. It is worth noting that some players have observed that rolling is not possible unless a weapon is equipped.
Incense and Pichu: What's the Connection?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
This issue could be occurring due to a bug in the game. Some players have reported that the quest is marked as "failed" even after completion.
There is currently no known fix for this bug. However, some players suggest that helping the Squirrels may bring the quest to a close.
If you refuse to give the recipe, the scholar will respond with a threat, saying "We'll meet again". The player may then encounter the scholar and his henchmen in the forest, resulting in a fight.
