The Fragrance Conundrum: Aftershave Vs. Cologne

Aftershave and cologne are two different products with distinct purposes. Aftershave is meant to be used after shaving to calm and soothe the skin. It also helps to seal and clean the pores. Aftershaves usually contain moisturising ingredients like aloe vera or shea butter, and have antiseptic properties that can help prevent skin irritation. On the other hand, cologne is designed specifically to make you smell good and does not offer any shaving-related benefits. While you can use aftershave as cologne, the opposite is not true as cologne is not formulated to address skin irritation from shaving.

Aftershave is a skincare product

There are four different forms of aftershave: lotion, gel, cream, and balm. Each form offers unique benefits and caters to different preferences and skin types. Aftershave lotions often contain alcohol, which can be drying, but they also contain moisturising ingredients such as glycerin, aloe vera, and vitamin E. Gels have a lightweight texture that absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy residue, making them suitable for oily or combination skin. Aftershave creams have a rich, creamy texture that provides deep hydration and nourishment, suitable for all skin types, especially dry skin. Balms have a thicker consistency that can vary depending on the formula and offer intense hydration, making them ideal for sensitive or dry skin.

When choosing an aftershave, consider your skin type, preferences, and any specific concerns. Experimenting with different forms of aftershaves can help you find the ideal product that suits your needs and enhances your shaving experience. Aftershave is meant to be used after shaving to calm and soothe the skin, and it is typically scented but not very strongly. On the other hand, cologne is designed specifically to make you smell good and does not offer shaving-related benefits. While you can use aftershave in place of cologne, cologne should not be used as a substitute for aftershave, as it is not formulated to address irritation from shaving.

Cologne is a fragrance product

The ideal places to apply cologne are the pulse points, the warmest parts of your body. Behind the ear, on the neck, wrist, or inner portion of the elbow are ideal places. Cologne should be sprayed at a distance of about 15cm from the skin to create a mist that diffuses over a good proportion of the skin area. This allows the fragrance to mingle with your natural scent, rather than masking it.

Cologne is weaker than eau de toilette, which contains 5-8% perfume oil, compared to 3-4% in cologne. Parfum is the strongest fragrance option, with an average of 15-25% perfume oil. Cologne is, therefore, a good option for those who want a powerful scent but do not want to opt for an eau de parfum or parfum.

While cologne is designed to be a fragrance product, aftershave has a greater purpose beyond enhancing your scent. Aftershave is designed to be applied directly to the skin after shaving to soothe, protect and nourish sensitive skin. It contains antiseptic ingredients and alcohol, as well as a small proportion of essential oils to give it a delicate scent. Aftershave can be used as a substitute for cologne if you wish to be fragranced with something very light. However, it will not have the same lasting power as cologne.

Aftershave has a lower concentration of fragrance oils

Aftershaves are primarily used to soothe the skin after shaving, providing relief from irritation. They often come in liquid or lotion form and contain ingredients like alcohol, witch hazel, aloe vera, and other soothing agents. The low concentration of fragrance oils in aftershave means that it provides a subtle scent that dissipates relatively quickly.

On the other hand, colognes are designed specifically to make you smell good. They are one of the most popular fragrance options for men and offer a stronger scent than an aftershave. Colognes often feature citrus, herbal, or aromatic notes, creating a refreshing and invigorating effect.

While you can use aftershave in place of cologne if you want a subtle fragrance, the inverse is not true. Do not replace your aftershave with cologne, as cologne will not be formulated to address the irritation that can come from shaving.

Cologne has a longer-lasting scent

Cologne: A Longer-Lasting Scent

Cologne is designed to make you smell good and is one of the most popular fragrance options for men. It offers a stronger scent than aftershave and typically contains around 3-4% perfume oil. The higher concentration of perfume oil in cologne means that it will last longer on the skin than aftershave.

How to Make Cologne Last Longer

There are several ways to make your cologne last longer. Firstly, it is recommended to apply it right after a shower as your pores are at their most open, allowing the cologne to seep into your skin. Moisturising beforehand is also beneficial as it helps the cologne absorb more efficiently.

You should also apply cologne to your pulse points, such as your wrists and neck, as these areas are warmer and help scents remain strong and fully develop. However, avoid rubbing your wrists together as this can "bruise the scent", causing it to break down faster.

Layering Fragrances

Layering your fragrance with complementary products such as soaps, aftershaves, and body balms can help to remove competing scents and make your cologne last longer. However, avoid spraying cologne directly onto your clothes as this can damage the garment and cause the scent to dissipate more quickly due to airflow.

Cologne vs Aftershave

While cologne is designed specifically to make you smell good, aftershave is meant to be used after shaving and offers skin benefits such as calming and soothing irritated skin. Aftershave is typically scented but not very strongly, with about 1-2% perfume oil being standard.

Although cologne has a stronger scent and lasts longer than aftershave, it is important to note that you should not replace your aftershave with cologne as it is not formulated to address shaving irritation.

You can use both aftershave and cologne

Aftershave has a very light fragrance, with only about 1% fragrance oil, and the scent usually lasts for about an hour. Because of its low concentration of fragrance, you can use aftershave with abundance, ensuring full coverage over the shaved area.

Cologne, on the other hand, is specifically designed to make you smell good. It has a stronger scent than aftershave, with a 2-4% fragrance oil concentration, and will last longer—up to three hours. Cologne typically comes in a spray form and is applied to the pulse points, like the neck, wrist, or behind the ear.

Since aftershave has a light fragrance, using both cologne and aftershave together is an option. Just be sure to find scents that complement each other. For example, if you use a vanilla-scented aftershave, you might want to choose a cologne with similar warm base notes.

So, if you're looking for both the skincare benefits of aftershave and a longer-lasting fragrance, combining the two can be a great choice.

Frequently asked questions