Stetson Cologne And Aftershave: Are They Interchangeable?

Stetson is a classic men's fragrance line that includes both cologne and aftershave products. The cologne and aftershave are produced by the same company and are often sold together in gift sets. While the cologne and aftershave have the same scent, there are some differences between the two products in terms of concentration, viscosity, colour, and packaging size. The cologne has a higher concentration of fragrance, resulting in a stronger scent and longer-lasting effect compared to the aftershave. The cologne is also slightly darker in colour and comes in a larger bottle than the aftershave.

What are the differences between Stetson cologne and aftershave?

While colognes and aftershaves are often similar, there are some differences between Stetson cologne and aftershave. Firstly, the cologne usually has a higher concentration of fragrance, which gives it a stronger scent and makes it last longer than the aftershave. The cologne is also usually slightly darker in colour and may be harsher on the skin. In terms of packaging, the cologne typically comes in a larger bottle (50ml) compared to the aftershave (22.1ml).

In terms of scent, the cologne has been described as having a sharper, more wonderful depth than the aftershave, which is said to be brighter and sweeter. The cologne has notes of bergamot, lavender, carnation, amber, musk, vanilla, moss, and various woods, creating a spicy-mossy-floral scent with a faint barbershop tint. The aftershave has a similar scent but with more honey and less sharpness, which some find gives them a headache.

The cologne and aftershave are made by the same company, Coty, and are often sold together as a gift set. They are also usually the same viscosity and are both splash-ons with metal screw caps. Despite the differences, the cologne and aftershave are generally very similar, and some people may not be able to tell them apart.

What are the similarities between the two?

The similarities between Stetson cologne and aftershave are numerous. Firstly, both products are manufactured by the same company, Coty, and come in glass bottles with metal screw caps. They also have the same viscosity and are applied in the same way—as splash-ons.

In terms of scent, the cologne and aftershave are very similar, if not identical. The cologne has a higher concentration of fragrance, making it smell stronger and last longer than the aftershave. However, the aftershave is described as having a brighter and sweeter scent, with less sharpness and depth than the cologne. The cologne's scent is described as spicy-mossy-floral with a faint barbershop tint, while the aftershave is said to have a more classic Chypre profile.

Both the cologne and the aftershave contain a variety of ingredients, including alcohol, water, parfum, propylene glycol, diisopropyl adipate, C12-15 alkyl lactate, ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate, benzophenone, preservatives, and colouring agents. The top notes of both products include citrus scents like lime, lavender, clary sage, bergamot, and lemon. The middle notes feature carnation, patchouli, orris root, jasmine, vetiver, cedar, and geranium. Finally, the base notes of both the cologne and aftershave are honey, tonka, amber, musk, and vanilla.

While there are some differences in terms of scent strength and longevity, the Stetson cologne and aftershave share many similarities in terms of packaging, application, and scent profile.

What are the ingredients of Stetson cologne and aftershave?

The ingredients of Stetson cologne and aftershave are:

Cologne:

• Alcohol Denat
• Octylacrylamide Copolymer
• Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate
• Diisopropyl Adipate
• C12-15 Alkyl Lactate
• Coumarin
• Hydroxycitronellal
• Limonene
• Alpha-Isomethyl Ionone
• Gernaiol
• Butylphenyl Methylpropional
• Benzophenone-3
• Ethylhexyl Salicylate
• Butyl Methoxybenzoylmethane
• Linalool
• Hydrolyzed Jojoba Esters
• Evernia Furfuracea
• Propylene Glycol
• Eugenol
• Sodium Carbonate
• C12-16 Alcohols
• Evernia Prunastri
• Citral
• Benzyl Benzoate
• Benzyl Alcohol
• Citronellol
• Yellow 5
• Red 4
• Blue 1

Aftershave:

• Alcohol
• Water
• Parfum (including a lot of IFRA limited-use ingredients)
• Propylene Glycol (humectant)
• Diisopropyl Adipate and C12-15 alkyl lactate (emollients)
• Ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate and benzophenone (UV blockers)
• Preservatives
• Colouring agents

What is the history of the Stetson brand?

Stetson is an American brand of hat manufactured by the John B. Stetson Company. John B. Stetson was born in 1830 in East Orange, New Jersey, where his father, Stephen Stetson, was a hatter. John B. Stetson gained inspiration for his most famous hats when he headed west from his native New Jersey for health reasons. On his return east in 1865, he founded the John B. Stetson Company in Philadelphia. He created a hat that has become symbolic of the pioneering American West, the "Boss of the Plains". This Western hat would become the cornerstone of Stetson's hat business and is still in production today.

John B. Stetson's western adventures came to an end in 1865. Stetson, then 35 years old and in better health, returned east and established his own hat firm in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, which produced high-quality hats for outdoor use. After producing some initial designs based on popular styles of the day, Stetson decided to create a hat based on his experiences in the American West, which he called the "Boss of the Plains". The high-crowned, wide-brimmed, soft-felt western hats that followed are intimately associated with the American cowboy image.

Stetson eventually became the world's largest hat maker, producing more than 3,300,000 hats a year in a factory spread over 9 acres in Philadelphia. In addition to its Western and fashion hats, Stetson also produces fragrances, apparel, footwear, eyewear, belts, bourbon, and other products evoking the historic American West.

In 1981, Stetson released their first cologne, the original one you still find today. It’s a classic that embodies the purple mountains in the West with cedar, pine, and fir. The cologne also captured the spirit of the Western frontiers, landscapes, and the smell of sage after a downpour.

Stetson set a new legacy in motion, and it all began with a friendly encounter.

What are the reviews of the two products?

Reviews of the Stetson cologne and aftershave vary. One user describes the cologne as having a "stronger scent" and lasting longer than the aftershave. Another user describes the cologne as "harsher on [their] skin" than the aftershave.

The cologne has received positive reviews on Amazon, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars from 3,671 global ratings. One review describes the cologne as having a preferable scent that is "woody yet aromatic". Another review states that it is their husband's favorite cologne.

The aftershave has also received positive reviews on Amazon, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from 3,110 global ratings. One review states that the aftershave has a subtle fabulous smell and that they have received many compliments on the fragrance. Another review mentions that the aftershave is great for everyday use.

A review on Reddit gives the aftershave a SpongeScore of 3/10, describing the fragrance as "less pleasant" than the cologne and "GROSSLY overpriced". However, the review also mentions that the aftershave has significant staying power.

Overall, both the Stetson cologne and aftershave have received mostly positive reviews, with some users preferring the scent and longevity of the cologne, while others appreciate the subtlety and effectiveness of the aftershave.

Frequently asked questions