Old Spice Cologne: Worth The Hype?

Old Spice is a classic men's fragrance that has been around since the 1930s. With its warm and spicy scent, it has garnered a loyal following over the years, with many men incorporating it into their daily routine. The cologne has a higher intensity than the aftershave, but both are designed to leave a lasting impression. While some associate the scent with older men, it is also popular among younger generations who appreciate its retro appeal. Women's reactions to the fragrance are mixed, with some finding it comforting and attractive, while others dislike it due to its strong scent or associations with older relatives. Ultimately, the decision to wear Old Spice comes down to personal preference, as scent preferences vary based on individual chemistry and taste.

Is Old Spice a good gift for older men?

Opinions vary on whether Old Spice is a good cologne for older men to wear. Some people associate the scent with older men, with one person describing it as "old/cheap". However, others describe it as sexy and a classic. One person even said that they can't keep the girls off of them when they are wearing it.

Some people who have worn Old Spice since they were younger continue to wear it as they get older, with one person saying they have been wearing it for 50 years. However, others are put off by the 'old man' connotations, especially those in their 20s.

The scent of Old Spice seems to be very nostalgic for some people, reminding them of their fathers or grandfathers. One person said that the scent is comforting and reminds them of their childhood. However, due to this association, some people would not want their partner to wear it.

Overall, it seems that Old Spice is a well-liked cologne, with many people receiving compliments when they wear it. One person said that it is "one of the sexiest skin-scents a man can wear".

Therefore, if you are thinking of buying Old Spice as a gift for an older man, it could be a good choice, especially if he used to wear it when he was younger.

What are some similar alternatives to Old Spice?

If you're looking for a similar alternative to Old Spice, there are several options available. One option is to explore vintage fragrances from the 1960s and 1970s that attempted to replicate the scent of Old Spice. These include spicy Avon aftershaves, such as "Wild Country", as well as other creations from that era. Another similar option is Royall Spyce, which is said to smell almost identical to Old Spice but with better-quality ingredients.

If you're open to trying something a little different, Creed Viking is described as a "higher-quality Old Spice" with good longevity. Barrister and Mann Spice EDC is another take on Old Spice with a more interesting citrus opening, but it still dries down to a scent that is very similar to Old Spice.

For something in the same ballpark as Old Spice, but not identical, you could try Jaïpur Homme or Calvin Klein Obsession for Men. These fragrances are cheap to experiment with and fall into the same spicy scent category as Old Spice. Paul Sebastian PS fine cologne is another very similar option that has been endorsed by multiple sources.

Lastly, if you're looking for a classic, masculine fragrance that will last through sweat and fieldwork, you might want to try Eau Sauvage Parfum by Dior, Pasha de Cartier Parfum, Bogart by Jacques Bogart, or One Man Show, also by Jacques Bogart. While these fragrances don't smell like Old Spice, they are long-lasting and are enhanced by the heat of the body.

Is Old Spice a good fragrance for younger men?

Whether or not Old Spice is a good fragrance for younger men is subjective and depends on individual preference. However, there are a variety of opinions on the internet from people of various ages, which may help inform your decision.

Some people associate the scent of Old Spice with older men, or with their fathers or grandfathers, and may find it off-putting for that reason. One person said that the scent is "old/cheap" and doesn't give it a chance for that reason. Another said that their mother and girlfriend "can't stand it" and that it reminds them of "something old and wrinkly".

On the other hand, many people like the scent of Old Spice, and some specifically mention that they are young and like it. One person said that they are 28 and find it "SSSEEEEXXXYYYY!!!!!!!" Another said that they are 23 and have "never had one complaint". Several people mention that they think women like the scent because it reminds them of their fathers, and that this makes it attractive. One person said that they are 20 and "love the stuff", and that "people will ask you what it is and be surprised when you say Old Spice". Another said that they are 26 and that "you'd be surprised how much ladies my age like Aqua Velva and Old Spice".

It is worth noting that some people have mentioned that the formula for Old Spice has changed over the years, and that newer versions smell different from older versions. One person said that the newer version is "slightly modernized", while another said that the newer version "smells good, but sweeter and more floral than the [old version]".

What are some positive associations with the scent of Old Spice?

Old Spice has been a popular fragrance for men since the 1930s. While some people associate the scent with their fathers or grandfathers, it has generally received positive reviews. Here are some of the positive associations with the scent of Old Spice:

Nostalgic and Comforting

Many people, especially women, associate the scent of Old Spice with their father or grandfather and their childhood. It evokes feelings of comfort and nostalgia, reminding them of happy memories and a sense of security.

Masculine and Attractive

Old Spice is often described as a masculine and attractive fragrance. Some women find it sexy and appealing when worn by men. The scent has a warm, spicy, and comforting effect, enhancing the physical attractiveness of the wearer.

Classic and Timeless

Old Spice is considered a classic and timeless fragrance. Its long history and staying power in the market demonstrate its enduring appeal. Despite being associated with older men, younger generations also appreciate its unique and distinct scent.

High-Quality and Long-Lasting

People appreciate the high quality and longevity of the Old Spice scent. It is known to have a strong intensity that lasts throughout the day. The cologne is often preferred over the aftershave due to its longer-lasting fragrance.

Versatile and Widely Appreciated

Old Spice is versatile, receiving compliments from people of different ages and backgrounds. It is widely appreciated, with many women expressing their fondness for the scent. The positive reactions to the fragrance boost the confidence of the wearer.

While individual preferences vary, Old Spice has stood the test of time and continues to be a popular choice for men's fragrance, creating positive associations and memories for those who encounter it.

What are some negative associations with the scent of Old Spice?

While Old Spice has been described as "good stuff", "nice", "warm", "cuddly", "divine", "sexy", "classic", "comforting", and "manly", there are some negative associations with the scent.

Some people have noted that the scent of Old Spice has changed over the years, with the newer formulation smelling "cheaper", "more floral and powdery", and "sweeter" than the original. Some long-time users of the cologne have expressed disappointment with the new scent, finding it "common" and not special.

For others, the scent of Old Spice is off-putting because of its association with older men, with some describing it as smelling "old" and "wrinkly". One person even stated that the scent of Old Spice is the only fragrance that makes them "physically sick".

Additionally, some people have a negative association with the scent due to familial connections, with several women stating that they would not want their partners to wear it because it reminds them of their fathers or grandfathers.

Frequently asked questions