Cologne As Aftershave: Good Or Bad Idea?

While cologne and aftershave are often used interchangeably, they are not the same thing. Aftershave is primarily a skincare product designed to be applied to the skin after shaving to soothe, protect and nourish sensitive skin. It usually contains antiseptic ingredients and alcohol, as well as essential oils to give it a delicate scent. Cologne, on the other hand, is a fragrance product designed to make you smell good. It contains a higher concentration of fragrance oils than aftershave, resulting in a stronger and longer-lasting scent. So, can you use cologne as an aftershave?

Cologne is a stronger scent

While you can use aftershave in place of cologne if you want a subtle fragrance, the opposite is not true. Cologne should not be used as a substitute for aftershave, as it won't have the same skincare benefits and could be too strong for your skin post-shaving.

If you're looking for a longer-lasting fragrance, cologne is the better option. It has a higher concentration of fragrance oils, so the scent will be more concentrated and last longer. However, be mindful of how much cologne you use, as a little goes a long way.

The ideal places to apply cologne are your pulse points, such as behind the ear, on the neck, wrist, or inner portion of the elbow. These areas emit more heat, which helps to lift the fragrance and make it last all day.

When applying cologne, it's best to spray at a distance of about 15cm from the skin to create a subtle mist that mingles with your natural scent. Avoid rubbing the fragrance into the skin, as this can break down the scent and reduce its longevity.

Aftershave has skincare benefits

Aftershave has evolved from the traditional alcohol-based formulas that caused a stinging sensation on the skin. While some aftershaves still contain alcohol, many now contain a range of skincare ingredients aimed at helping various skin issues.

Aftershave is important for your skincare routine as it offers hydration and protection. Shaving can dry out the skin, causing it to feel tight and prickly due to a lack of moisture. Aftershave helps to alleviate these effects by adding moisture back into the skin, leaving it feeling soft, soothed, and moisturised.

Aftershave also helps to stop the spread of bacteria and neutralise the odds of infection, razor bumps, ingrown hairs, and more. Ingredients like tea tree oil and witch hazel naturally neutralise bacteria and prevent post-shave breakouts without drying out the skin.

Additionally, aftershave can soothe and calm the skin. Ingredients like aloe vera and eucalyptus relieve pain, prevent redness and irritation, and turn the post-shave burn into a tingle.

Aftershave can also help to reduce itching and swelling from skin damage and ingrown hairs, close pores to prevent bacteria, dirt, or chemicals from getting in, promote the regrowth of skin tissue, and add a pleasant smell to your skin.

Cologne is not for use on the face

While cologne and aftershave may be similar in some ways, they are not interchangeable. Using cologne as aftershave is not advisable, as cologne is not formulated for use on the face.

The Purpose of Aftershave

Aftershave is designed to be applied to the face after shaving. Its primary purpose is to soothe, protect, and nourish the skin, particularly in areas where the skin is sensitive from shaving. Aftershave contains antiseptic ingredients, such as alcohol, that disinfect open pores, cuts, and nicks, while also reducing irritation, redness, and skin damage.

The Purpose of Cologne

In contrast, cologne is a fragrance designed to make you smell good. It does not offer the same skincare benefits as aftershave. Cologne contains a higher concentration of fragrance oils, which gives it a stronger scent than aftershave. Applying cologne to the face may cause skin irritation, especially on freshly shaved skin.

Using Aftershave and Cologne Together

While cologne should not be used as a substitute for aftershave, the two products can be used together. Aftershave can be applied to the face to calm and nourish the skin, while cologne can be used on the pulse points of the body to enhance your fragrance.

Choosing the Right Product

When deciding whether to use aftershave, cologne, or both, it is important to consider your specific needs and the occasion. If you are looking for a product to soothe and protect your skin after shaving, then aftershave is the best choice. If you want a stronger fragrance to last throughout the day or for a special event, cologne is a better option. By understanding the purpose and benefits of each product, you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

Cologne lasts longer

While colognes and aftershaves are not the same thing, you can use an aftershave in place of cologne. If you want a subtle fragrance, wear your aftershave without any cologne or other fragranced products. Aftershave is the weakest on the fragrance scale, with only about 1% fragrance oil, so the scent generally lasts for about an hour, but some can last up to two to three hours.

On the other hand, colognes have a stronger scent than aftershaves, with a 2-4% fragrance oil concentration, and the scent can last up to three hours. However, you will need to reapply after this time if you want to maintain the fragrance.

If you want a longer-lasting fragrance, it is better to add a spritz or two of cologne before heading out. You can also use both cologne and aftershave together, but be sure to find scents that complement each other.

Colognes are designed to make you smell good and do not offer shaving-related benefits, whereas aftershave is meant to be used after shaving and offers skin benefits, helping to calm, protect, and soothe the skin.

Aftershave is best for sensitive skin

While cologne is designed to make you smell good, aftershave is formulated to calm and soothe your skin after shaving, reducing irritation, redness, and razor bumps. Aftershave is therefore a better option for those with sensitive skin.

If you have sensitive skin, it's best to opt for an aftershave that is alcohol-free, as alcohol can be drying and irritating. Many aftershaves are designed specifically for sensitive skin, such as those formulated with oatmeal and green tea, which can help to soothe and protect inflamed skin.

Some popular options for aftershave for sensitive skin include:

• Nivea Men Sensitive Soothing Post Shave Balm with Vitamin E, Chamomile, and Witch Hazel Extracts
• Bee Bald Heal Aftershave for Men Healing Balm
• Cremo Sensitive Post Shave Balm
• Proraso After Shave Balm for Sensitive Skin
• Kiehl's Ultimate Razor Burn & Bump Relief
• The Art of Shaving After-Shave Balm for Men

These products are designed to calm and moisturize the skin after shaving, providing relief from irritation and redness. They are typically lightly fragranced or fragrance-free, so they won't irritate sensitive skin.

While you can use aftershave in place of cologne, it is not recommended to use cologne as an aftershave, as it won't have the same skin-soothing benefits and could potentially irritate freshly shaved skin.

Frequently asked questions