Cologne: Antibacterial Or Not?

There is a lot of misinformation about the antimicrobial properties of cologne. While cologne contains alcohol, a key ingredient in hand sanitizers, cologne is not an effective disinfectant. Cologne has a high percentage of alcohol, but it is not intended to be used as a disinfectant or sanitiser. It is important to note that cologne is not a replacement for hand sanitiser or proper handwashing with soap and water.

Cologne is not an effective disinfectant

While cologne contains alcohol, which is a key ingredient in hand sanitizers, cologne is not an effective disinfectant.

Firstly, cologne does not contain enough alcohol to be an effective disinfectant. Commercial hand sanitizers contain between 60-70% alcohol, while perfumes and colognes range between 70-97% alcohol. However, the higher concentration of alcohol in cologne is not ideal for killing microorganisms. Alcohol in a 50-80% solution kills microorganisms by creating holes in their cell walls, allowing water from the solution to rush in and cause lysis. At higher concentrations of alcohol, the cell wall is not completely breached, and the alcohol evaporates too quickly for sufficient contact time.

Secondly, cologne does not contain enough water to be an effective disinfectant. At high concentrations of alcohol, the outermost proteins of the cell wall can be coagulated, sealing the cell and preventing water from entering and causing the cell to die. Commercial hand sanitizers are based on alcohol but also contain water or water-containing ingredients such as aloe vera gel, which is over 90% water.

Thirdly, cologne is not intended to be used as a disinfectant. Fragrance oils are not meant to be used in leave-on products in large quantities, and certain oils and aromachemicals are restricted in their use in perfumes. Using cologne as a disinfectant would involve rubbing it into the hands in larger amounts than usual, increasing the risk of skin irritation or allergic reactions.

Finally, cologne is not a replacement for proper hand hygiene. Even properly made commercial hand sanitizers are much less effective than regular hand-washing with soap and water. Hand sanitizers should only be used as a temporary measure when soap and water are not available.

In conclusion, while cologne may contain a high percentage of alcohol, it is not an effective disinfectant due to its lower percentage of alcohol compared to commercial hand sanitizers, lack of sufficient water, potential skin irritation, and inferiority to proper hand-washing with soap and water.

Cologne is not an effective antimicrobial

While cologne does contain alcohol, which is an important ingredient in hand sanitiser, cologne is not an effective antimicrobial or disinfectant. This is because the alcohol content in cologne is not high enough to be effective. Commercial hand sanitisers contain between 60-70% alcohol, whereas perfumes range from 70-97% alcohol. However, the higher concentration of alcohol in perfume means that the alcohol will evaporate quickly, meaning it will not be in contact with the skin for long enough to kill microorganisms.

In addition, cologne does not contain enough water. At higher concentrations of alcohol, the outermost proteins of the cell wall are coagulated, which seals the cell, but water does not enter so the cell does not die. Therefore, cologne is not an effective antimicrobial as it does not contain the right balance of alcohol and water.

Furthermore, cologne is not intended to be used as a leave-on product in large quantities, and certain oils and aromachemicals are restricted in their use in perfumes. Using cologne as a hand sanitiser could therefore lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions, or cause photo-sensitisation, a term used when an oil induces rapid tanning of the skin resulting in reddening or permanent hyperpigmentation.

Overall, while cologne does contain some ingredients that could be effective against microorganisms, it is not a reliable or safe alternative to hand sanitiser or other antimicrobial products.

Cologne can be used as hand sanitiser in an emergency

The role of alcohol in hand sanitiser

Hand sanitiser is typically made up of alcohol, water or water-containing ingredients, and other components such as aloe vera gel, glycerine, and natural oils. Alcohol is the active ingredient that kills bacteria, viruses, and fungi by causing holes in the cell walls of these organisms, leading to their death. To be effective, hand sanitiser needs to contain a minimum of 60% alcohol, with the healthcare sector often using sanitisers with 70-95% alcohol content.

Cologne as an emergency option

Cologne can be used as a hand sanitiser in an emergency when no other options are available. However, it is important to note that cologne is not specifically designed or tested for this purpose and may not be as effective as a commercial hand sanitiser. The concentration of alcohol in cologne may vary, and it is typically not designed to be used in large quantities on the skin, which could lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions.

Best practices for hand hygiene

While cologne can be used as a last resort, it is important to prioritise hand-washing with soap and water as the most effective way to maintain hand hygiene. Hand sanitiser should be used as a temporary measure when soap and water are not accessible. Regular hand-washing and sanitising are basic hygiene routines that can significantly prevent the spread of viruses and bacteria.

Cologne is not a replacement for hand sanitiser

While cologne contains alcohol, a key ingredient in hand sanitiser, it is not an effective replacement for hand sanitiser.

Firstly, cologne does not contain water or water-containing ingredients, which are necessary components of hand sanitiser. At high concentrations of alcohol, the outermost proteins of the cell wall can be coagulated, "sealing" the cell and preventing water from entering and killing the cell. Therefore, cologne is not as effective as hand sanitiser at killing microorganisms.

Secondly, cologne is not intended to be used as a leave-on product in large quantities. The overapplication of cologne on the hands may lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions, or the oils may cause photo-sensitisation, a term used when an oil induces rapid tanning of the skin, resulting in reddening or permanent hyperpigmentation, or skin cell damage.

Thirdly, cologne is not tested as a body-cleansing or hygiene product but as a fragrance cosmetic. Therefore, using cologne as hand sanitiser would be using the product in a way that is not intended by the manufacturer, and the manufacturer would not be liable for any adverse reactions.

Finally, even properly made commercial hand sanitisers are much less effective than regular hand-washing with soap and water. Hand sanitisers should only be used as a temporary measure until you can wash your hands properly.

In conclusion, cologne is not a replacement for hand sanitiser.

Cologne may cause skin irritation

While cologne has disinfectant properties due to its alcohol content, it is not an effective replacement for hand sanitiser or soap and water. Overuse of cologne on the skin may lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions.

Cologne is not intended to be used as a leave-on product in large quantities, and certain oils and aromachemicals are restricted in their use in perfumes. If used as a hand sanitiser, cologne will be rubbed into the hands in larger amounts over a large portion of skin, rather than dabbed or sprayed on pulse points.

The use of cologne as a hand sanitiser may cause photo-sensitisation, a term used when an oil induces rapid tanning of the skin, resulting in reddening or permanent hyperpigmentation, or skin cell damage.

Perfumes undergo safety testing and are issued with a Cosmetics Portal Safety Report (EU) to be placed on the market. However, if you use cologne as a hand sanitiser and experience an adverse reaction, the manufacturer will not be liable as you have used the product in a way that is not intended.

Therefore, while cologne may have some disinfectant properties, it is not a suitable replacement for hand sanitiser or proper handwashing with soap and water, and its overuse may lead to skin irritation and other adverse reactions.

Frequently asked questions