Cologne: A Sanitary Alternative?

The ongoing debate about whether cologne can be used as a disinfectant has been a topic of discussion for many, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. While cologne does contain alcohol, which is a key ingredient in hand sanitizers, it is not an effective replacement for hand sanitizers or disinfectants. The purpose of cologne is to be worn as a fragrance, and using it as a disinfectant may lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions. It is important to understand that while cologne may have a high percentage of alcohol, it is not designed or tested for disinfecting or sanitizing and should not be relied upon for that purpose.

Cologne has a high percentage of alcohol, which is effective in killing viruses, bacteria and fungi

It is true that cologne has a high percentage of alcohol, which is a key ingredient in killing viruses, bacteria, and fungi. However, it is important to note that cologne is not specifically designed or tested for use as a disinfectant or sanitiser. While the alcohol content in cologne may have some antimicrobial effects, it is not as effective as commercial hand sanitisers or proper handwashing with soap and water.

The effectiveness of hand sanitisers depends on the concentration of alcohol, which should be between 60-95%. Commercial hand sanitisers typically contain between 60-70% alcohol, while perfumes and colognes generally range from 70-97% alcohol. Although cologne may fall within this range, its primary purpose is as a fragrance, not a sanitising agent.

Additionally, cologne is not placed on the market or tested as a hygiene product. The fragrance oils and aromachemicals used in cologne are not intended for leave-on products in large quantities and may have restrictions on their use. As a result, using cologne as a hand sanitiser may lead to skin irritation, allergic reactions, or photo-sensitisation.

Furthermore, the scent of cologne may be overpowering when used as a hand sanitiser, and the presence of additional fragrance oils may reduce the effectiveness of the alcohol as a disinfectant. While cologne may have a high percentage of alcohol, it is not a suitable replacement for commercial hand sanitisers or proper handwashing.

In summary, while cologne contains a high percentage of alcohol, which can be effective in killing viruses, bacteria, and fungi, it is not specifically designed, tested, or recommended for use as a hand sanitiser. The potential risks of skin irritation and allergic reactions, along with the overpowering scent, make cologne a less ideal option for sanitisation compared to commercial hand sanitisers or proper handwashing with soap and water.

Cologne is not an effective replacement for hand sanitiser as it is not designed for this purpose

While cologne does contain alcohol, which is a key ingredient in hand sanitiser, it is not an effective replacement for hand sanitiser as it is not designed for this purpose.

Firstly, cologne is not designed to be used as a hand sanitiser or hygiene product. It is a fragrance cosmetic, intended to be dabbed or sprayed on pulse points and allowed to evaporate. When used as a hand sanitiser, cologne is rubbed into the hands in larger amounts and comes into contact with a large portion of skin, which could lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions.

Secondly, cologne does not contain the correct concentration of alcohol to be effective against microorganisms. Commercial hand sanitisers contain between 60-70% alcohol, while cologne contains around 1-3% fragrance. At high concentrations of alcohol, the outermost proteins of the cell can be coagulated, "sealing" the cell and rendering it ineffective.

Additionally, hand sanitisers often contain other ingredients such as aloe vera gel, glycerine, and natural oils, which act as humectants and moisturisers to counteract the drying effect of alcohol on the skin. Cologne does not contain these additional ingredients and may not provide the same level of skin protection.

Furthermore, the strong scent of cologne may be overpowering when used as a hand sanitiser, and over-liberal use may result in exposure to fragrance allergens, potentially causing skin irritation or allergic reactions.

Therefore, while cologne may contain some similar ingredients to hand sanitiser, it is not designed or intended to be used as a replacement for hand sanitiser and may not provide the same level of protection against microorganisms. It is always best to use products for their intended purpose and follow public health guidelines for hand hygiene and sanitation.

Cologne may contain fragrance oils that are restricted in their use in leave-on products

While cologne may contain a high enough percentage of alcohol to be effective in killing some viruses, bacteria, and fungi, it is not a suitable replacement for hand sanitizer. This is because colognes are not tested as body cleansing or hygiene products and may contain fragrance oils that are restricted in their use in leave-on products.

Cologne is a type of perfume typically containing 1-3% fragrance. While the high alcohol content in cologne may make it seem like an ideal substitute for hand sanitizer, it is important to remember that cologne is not designed or tested for this purpose. Fragrance oils found in colognes are not intended to be used in large quantities on the skin, and certain oils and aromachemicals are restricted in their use in leave-on products like cologne.

When used as a hand sanitizer, cologne is rubbed into the hands in larger amounts and comes into contact with a large portion of the skin. This is in contrast to typical cologne application, where it is dabbed or sprayed on pulse points and left to evaporate. Overuse of cologne on the hands may increase exposure to fragrance allergens, potentially causing skin irritation, allergic reactions, or photo-sensitisation (rapid tanning of the skin resulting in reddening or permanent hyperpigmentation).

Additionally, the scent of cologne used as a hand sanitizer may be overpowering and unpleasant. Ann Prosser of Cosmetic Safety Assessment firm Oxford Biosciences warns that while old perfumes could technically be used as hand sanitizers due to their high alcohol content, the strong fragrance on the hands would be undesirable.

In conclusion, while cologne may contain alcohol that can help kill microorganisms, it is not a suitable replacement for hand sanitizer due to the potential risks associated with the fragrance oils it contains. It is important to use products for their intended purposes and follow guidelines for effective hand hygiene and sanitation.

Overuse of cologne on hands may cause skin irritation or an allergic reaction

While cologne contains alcohol, which is an ingredient in hand sanitiser, cologne is not an effective disinfectant or antimicrobial. This is because cologne does not contain enough water, and the alcohol content is too high. The alcohol in cologne evaporates quickly, so the contact time with the skin is not sufficient to kill microorganisms.

Furthermore, colognes contain an array of compounds, many of which are not specified on the label. Up to 30% of the US population has experienced discomfort from perfume, according to a 2009 fragrance allergy survey. Fragrance allergies can cause a range of symptoms, including rashes, itching, irritation, blistering, sneezing, and headaches. In more severe cases, fragrance allergies can cause swelling of the tongue, lips, or mouth, and anaphylaxis.

Therefore, overuse of cologne on the hands may lead to skin irritation or an allergic reaction, particularly for those with fragrance allergies or sensitivities. It is not a suitable replacement for hand sanitiser or soap and water, and should not be used as a disinfectant.

Using cologne as a hand sanitiser will leave an overpowering scent on your hands

Using cologne as a hand sanitiser is not a good idea, especially if you are sensitive to strong scents. While cologne does contain a high percentage of alcohol, which is effective in killing viruses, bacteria and fungi, it is not intended to be used as a sanitising product.

The use of cologne as a hand sanitiser will result in an overpowering scent on your hands. Ann Prosser of Cosmetic Safety Assessment firm Oxford Biosciences states:

> It would be fine to use old perfumes as hand sanitisers, as with the high percentage of alcohol they would work. But the smell on your hands would be overpowering! I certainly wouldn’t apply perfume more than twice a day and then I’m always fully clothed so most of it goes onto fabric rather than skin.

The scent of cologne is designed to be enjoyed in small doses, dabbed or sprayed on pulse points, and is not intended to be rubbed into the skin in large amounts. The application of cologne as a hand sanitiser will result in an intense and overwhelming aroma.

In addition to the overpowering scent, the use of cologne as a hand sanitiser may also cause skin irritation or allergic reactions due to the concentration of fragrance oils and aromachemicals. These oils can also cause photo-sensitisation, a term used when an oil induces rapid tanning of the skin, resulting in reddening or permanent hyperpigmentation.

Therefore, while cologne does contain a high percentage of alcohol, it is not an effective replacement for hand sanitiser due to its overpowering scent and potential skin irritation. It is important to use products as intended and opt for commercially available hand sanitisers that are designed for sanitising purposes.

Frequently asked questions