American Eagle Cologne: Worth The Hype?

American Eagle has released several colognes for men, including Real for Him, Surf, Fear Nothing, and Aura. The colognes have received mixed reviews, with some people praising the scent and longevity, while others find it too weak or too sweet. Some reviewers note that the scent is better suited for younger men, particularly those in high school or middle school, while others find it too common due to its use in American Eagle stores. Ultimately, the preference for a cologne is subjective, and what smells good to one person may not smell good to another.

American Eagle cologne reviews

American Eagle has released several colognes over the years, including "Real", "Fear Nothing", and "1977". Here is a collection of reviews for these colognes:

American Eagle "Real" Cologne

Reviews for this cologne are generally positive, with some users saying it smells "amazing" and that it's the best compliment they receive. However, it appears that this cologne has been discontinued, with some users stocking up on bottles. Similar colognes suggested by other users include Guerlain Homme and Guerlain Homme l'eau Boisee.

American Eagle "Fear Nothing" Cologne

Some users are fans of this cologne, with one saying they were pleasantly surprised by it. However, one user notes that the deodorant gave them a rash. Another user suggests trying the cologne in-store before purchasing, as fragrance preferences are subjective.

American Eagle "1977" Cologne

Reviews for this cologne are mixed. One user says it's "alright" but doesn't last long, while another says there are way better smells out there. However, some users are fans, with one saying they wish it was still available. This cologne also appears to have been discontinued, with some users seeking alternatives.

Fear Nothing cologne

American Eagle's Fear Nothing is a woody, aromatic fragrance for men and women. It was launched in 2017 and has top notes of black plum, rich sandalwood, and tonka bean.

Fear Nothing has received positive reviews from customers, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars on Amazon and 4.09 out of 5 on Fragrantica. Many reviewers mention that the fragrance smells amazing and is a great starter cologne, with one reviewer saying they received compliments on it. However, some reviewers note that the scent doesn't last long and requires multiple sprays to be effective.

The cologne is available in a 1.7-ounce Eau de Toilette bottle and can be purchased from Amazon, American Eagle, and other retailers. The price ranges from $42.25 to $59.95, with free shipping offered by some sellers.

Overall, American Eagle's Fear Nothing cologne is a well-reviewed, affordable option for those seeking a woody, aromatic fragrance. While it may not have a strong projection or longevity, it is a pleasant scent that can be suitable for daily wear.

Real cologne

Real by American Eagle is a Woody Spicy fragrance for men that was launched in 2006. The top notes of this cologne include green leaves, watery notes, mandarin orange, lemon, bergamot, and sea notes. The middle notes are cardamom, rose, orange blossom, and lily-of-the-valley, while the base notes are amber, vetiver, sandalwood, moss, resins, and patchouli.

The reviews for this cologne are mixed. Some people praise its light and crisp scent, describing it as mildly woody and fruity, while others find it too sweet and weak. One reviewer mentions that it is a simple, fun, and casual fragrance perfect for days when one is just lounging at home. Another reviewer mentions that the scent is reminiscent of their high school years and the mall, and they don't find it unique enough to purchase again.

The fragrance has a perfume rating of 4.20 out of 5 with 59 votes on Fragrantica.com. The same website also provides a breakdown of reviews, with 40% positive, 30% neutral, and 30% negative.

Overall, Real by American Eagle seems to be a good option for those looking for an affordable, light, and fruity cologne, especially for casual or relaxing occasions. However, those looking for a more unique or long-lasting scent may want to explore other options.

Surf cologne

American Eagle's Surf cologne for men is an aromatic aquatic fragrance. It was launched in 2019 and has received mostly positive reviews. The cologne has been described as having a "great scent" and "lasting forever", with one reviewer saying it "smells wonderful".

However, some reviewers have criticised the cologne for being too expensive, with one person saying that they did not like how it cost "four times" as much as it did a few years ago. Another common complaint is that the fragrance does not last long and is very weak. One reviewer said, ""Fragrances that smell this good shouldn't only last 1 hour. With the money AE makes yearly, you would think they would at least make this an EDT".

Despite this, the product has an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars on Amazon, with similar ratings on other sites. Overall, it seems that while American Eagle's Surf cologne has received some criticism, the majority of reviewers have enjoyed the scent and found it to be a good purchase.

If you are considering purchasing this cologne, it may be worth trying a tester or a small bottle first to see if it meets your expectations.

American Eagle cologne longevity

The longevity of a fragrance is an important factor to consider when choosing a cologne. The American Eagle cologne collection includes a range of scents with different longevity properties.

The American Eagle 1977 cologne, available in a 3.4 OZ bottle, has received positive reviews from customers who mention its long-lasting scent. They describe it as a great quality fragrance that lasts all day, even during construction work. This cologne seems to be a good option for those seeking longevity.

However, it is important to note that fragrance longevity can vary depending on individual factors such as skin type. Some reviewers of the American Eagle Live cologne have mentioned that the scent only lasts for 3-4 hours on their skin, which they consider a negative aspect.

The Fear Nothing line, including the Fear Nothing Bold and Fear Nothing Indigo colognes, offers a darker and richer fragrance profile. While reviews for these specific scents do not mention longevity, the positive reviews for the 1977 cologne suggest that American Eagle colognes have the potential to be long-lasting.

Additionally, the Undiscovered scent from American Eagle provides a brighter fragrance option with citrus notes. While there are no specific reviews mentioning longevity for this particular scent, the positive reviews for longevity across other American Eagle colognes suggest that this fragrance may also offer decent longevity.

Overall, while the longevity of a fragrance can vary depending on individual factors, American Eagle colognes seem to offer a range of long-lasting options, with the 1977 cologne being particularly noted for its lasting power.

Frequently asked questions