Whirlpooling Hops: Aroma Addition Or Extraction Technique?

Whirlpool hopping is a technique where hops are added after the flame-out and steeped at a high temperature before the wort is chilled. The primary purpose of whirlpool hopping is to capture volatile hop aroma oils in the beer. Most aroma oils in hops have a lower boiling point than water, so they will quickly boil off if added during the boil. Whirlpool hopping helps preserve these oils. Whirlpool hops are added at a temperature where isomerization still occurs, creating isomerized alpha acids, which are the main bittering compound in beer. Therefore, adding hops during the whirlpool will still add some bitterness to the beer.

Whirlpool hopping captures volatile aroma oils

Whirlpool hopping, or "steeped" hopping, is a technique where hops are added after flame-out and allowed to steep at a hot temperature before the wort is chilled. The primary purpose of whirlpool hopping is to capture volatile hop aroma oils, as most aroma oils in hops have a boiling point lower than that of water and will quickly boil off if added during the boil. Whirlpool hopping helps to preserve these oils.

The four primary hop aroma oils are myrcene, humulene, caryophyllene, and farnesene. Myrcene is the most abundant, comprising 40-60% of hop oils in most varieties and offering herbal, balsamic, or hoppy notes with potential piney/citrusy hints. Humulene, widely used in perfumes, has a strong herbal component and tends to produce a spicy flavour when boiled. Caryophyllene, found in many English hop varieties, provides spicy, earthy, and woody tones. Farnesene, typically found in noble hops, adds flowery, green apple, or woody notes.

To preserve the volatile oils in hops, it is necessary to steep them at a temperature below boiling. Whirlpool additions can be made within different temperature ranges to achieve specific outcomes. The high isomerization range of 185-210°F (85-99°C) still isomerizes alpha acids, adding bitterness, but there is a risk of vaporizing a large portion of the hop's flavour and aroma oils. The medium whirlpool range of 160-170°F (71-76°C) minimises isomerization, resulting in less bitterness, while still providing good solubility for the oils. The low whirlpool range of 150-160°F (60-66°C) volatilizes the fewest hop oils but requires a longer whirlpool time due to lower solubility.

While the main goal of whirlpool hopping is to capture aroma oils, isomerization of alpha hops still occurs, creating isomerized alpha acids, the main bittering compound in beer. Therefore, whirlpool hopping will add some bitterness to the beer. Additionally, the effect of boil hops that carry over into the whirlpool can further contribute to bitterness. As a result, the temperature and time of whirlpool additions are critical to achieving the desired balance of aroma and bitterness.

Whirlpool hopping is a technique where hops are added after flame-out

The primary purpose of whirlpool hopping is to capture volatile hop aroma oils in the beer. Most aroma oils in hops have a lower boiling point than water, so they will quickly boil off if added during the boil. Whirlpool hopping helps preserve these oils. While the main goal of whirlpool hopping is not to add bitterness, some bitterness will still be added to the beer as isomerization of the alpha hops still occurs at the whirlpool temperature.

There are different temperature ranges for whirlpool hopping, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The high whirlpool range of 185–210°F (85–99°C) is high enough to isomerize some hops alpha acids, adding bitterness to the beer. However, this range also risks vaporizing a large portion of the hop's flavour and aroma oils. The medium whirlpool range of 160–170°F (71–76°C) minimises isomerization, resulting in very little added bitterness. This range still provides good solubility for the oils, allowing you to preserve more of the hops' oils while requiring less whirlpool time. The low whirlpool range of 150–160°F (60–66°C) volatilizes the fewest hop oils, but due to the lower solubility at this temperature range, a longer whirlpool time is required.

Whirlpool hopping can add some bitterness to the beer

Whirlpool hopping is a technique where hops are added after flame-out and allowed to steep at a hot temperature for a period of time before the wort is chilled. The main purpose of whirlpool hopping is to capture volatile hop aroma oils in the beer. However, whirlpool hopping can also add some bitterness to the beer.

While the primary goal of whirlpool hopping is to capture aroma oils, the hops are added at a temperature where isomerization still occurs. Isomerization of alpha hops creates isomerized alpha acids, which are the main bittering compound in beer. Therefore, adding hops during the whirlpool stage will contribute some bitterness to the final product.

The level of bitterness imparted by whirlpool hopping depends on the temperature and duration of the process. Higher temperatures, such as those in the high isomerization range of 185–210°F (85–99°C), will result in more isomerization of alpha acids and, consequently, increased bitterness. On the other hand, lower temperatures in the medium whirlpool range of 160–170°F (71–76°C) will lead to less isomerization and minimal bitterness.

Additionally, the length of time that the hops are in contact with the hot wort also affects the amount of bitterness extracted. Longer whirlpool times, such as those used by professional brewers, generally result in more bitterness. However, there may be diminishing returns on bitterness extraction after a certain point, as suggested by the results of an experiment conducted by the American Homebrewers Association.

In summary, while the main objective of whirlpool hopping is to capture aroma oils, it can also contribute some bitterness to the beer. The temperature and duration of the whirlpool process play a significant role in determining the level of bitterness that will be present in the final beer.

Whirlpool hopping is used to preserve hops oils

Whirlpool hopping, or "steeped" hopping, is a technique where hops are added after flame-out and allowed to steep at hot temperatures before the wort is chilled. The main purpose of whirlpool hopping is to capture volatile hop aroma oils in the beer and prevent them from boiling off. Most aroma oils in hops have a boiling point lower than that of water, so by adding the hops in the whirlpool or as dry hops, these oils can be preserved.

To preserve the volatile oils in hops, it is necessary to steep them at a temperature below boiling. Whirlpool hops are primarily used for extracting these oils, which include myrcene, humulene, caryophyllene, and farnesene. Myrcene, the most prevalent of these oils, contributes an herbal, piney, or citrusy note to the beer. Humulene, commonly found in noble hops, adds spicy, herbal flavours. Caryophyllene, often found in English hop varieties, provides earthy, woody, and spicy tones. Farnesene, typically found in noble hops, adds flowery, green apple, or woody notes.

Whirlpool additions can be made at different temperature ranges to achieve varying levels of isomerization and oil preservation. The high isomerization range, between 185-210°F (85-99°C), allows for some isomerization of alpha acids, adding bitterness, but also carries the risk of vaporizing a large portion of the hop's flavour and aroma oils. The medium whirlpool range, between 160-170°F (71-76°C), minimises isomerization, reducing bitterness, while still providing sufficient heat to dissolve the oils. The low whirlpool range, between 150-160°F (60-66°C), further reduces the loss of volatile oils but requires a longer whirlpool time due to lower solubility at the lower temperature.

While whirlpool hopping does capture aroma oils, it is important to note that isomerization still occurs at these temperatures, resulting in some bitterness in the final beer. The temperature and time of whirlpool additions are critical to achieving the desired balance of bitterness and aroma.

Whirlpool hopping is more effective than short boil additions

Whirlpool hopping is a technique where hops are added after flame-out and allowed to steep at a hot temperature for a period before the wort is chilled. The main purpose of whirlpool hopping is to capture volatile hop aroma oils in the beer. Most aroma oils in hops have a boiling point lower than water, so they will quickly boil off if the hops are added during the boil. Therefore, hops are added either in the whirlpool or as dry hops to preserve these oils.

The temperature of the wort during the whirlpool stage is important as isomerisation still occurs at this stage, which creates isomerised alpha acids, the main bittering compound in beer. The higher the temperature, the more isomerisation will occur, and therefore the more bitterness will be created. The temperature ranges for whirlpooling are:

• High whirlpool range: 185-210°F (85-99°C). In this range, there is still some isomerisation occurring, adding bitterness to the beer. However, this range is so hot that there is a risk of vaporising a large portion of the hop's flavour and aroma oils.
• Medium whirlpool range: 160-170°F (71-76°C). In this range, little isomerisation occurs, so not much bitterness is added. Volatilisation is also reduced, so more hop oils are preserved. The wort is still hot enough for the oils to dissolve, making this range a good compromise.
• Low whirlpool range: 150-160°F (60-66°C). In this range, the fewest hop oils will be vaporised, but the hops will require a longer whirlpool time due to lower solubility at the lower temperature.

In summary, whirlpool hopping is more effective than short boil additions because it captures volatile hop aroma oils, which are lost during short boils. The temperature of the whirlpool stage is important to control as it determines the level of isomerisation and therefore the bitterness of the beer.

Frequently asked questions