Colognes: Do They Sanitize Or Just Mask Odor?

There is a lot of misinformation about the use of cologne as a disinfectant. While cologne often contains more than 60% alcohol, it is not an effective disinfectant or antimicrobial agent. It is important to note that disinfectants should not be harmful to the user and should not be affected by environmental factors. Cologne, on the other hand, can cause a severe burning sensation on open skin or wounds and should not be used for sterilisation. Additionally, cologne is not a cost-effective alternative to traditional disinfectants, and excessive use can lead to skin drying and topical dermatitis. It is also worth noting that fragrances are often used to cover up the smell of toxic chemicals and can be harmful to health.

Cologne is not an effective disinfectant

While cologne can be used as a disinfectant, it is not a good idea for several reasons. Firstly, cologne is not designed for this purpose and therefore may not be effective against all types of bacteria and viruses. For example, a recent German study found that ethanol, which is the main chemical component in cologne, was ineffective against the polio virus, Calci-virus, Hepatitis A virus, and foot and mouth virus.

Secondly, cologne can be extremely harmful to the skin, causing dryness and topical dermatitis with excessive use. It can also cause a severe burning sensation on open wounds and damage the tissues responsible for the healing process, which may lead to a delay in recovery.

Thirdly, colognes are often very expensive, and the amount needed to disinfect a surface would be much higher than that of a typical hand sanitizer or disinfectant. This makes cologne a very uneconomical choice for disinfection.

In addition, colognes are not always compatible with all surfaces and may cause corrosion or deterioration of certain materials such as cloth, rubber, and plastic. This limits their effectiveness as a disinfectant for everyday items.

Finally, colognes are often marketed with misleading claims about their disinfectant properties. Manufacturers are not required to disclose all ingredients, and the term "fragrance" can be used to hide a cocktail of toxic chemicals. These hidden ingredients can include harmful toxins that are dangerous to human health, such as hormone disruptors, neurotoxins, carcinogens, allergens, and asthma triggers.

Therefore, while cologne may have some disinfectant properties due to its high alcohol content, it is not a recommended substitute for proper disinfectants or hand sanitizers. It is always better to use running water and soap, or a commercial disinfectant with known ingredients, to ensure effective disinfection without the potential risks associated with cologne.

It can be used to sanitise non-critical items

While cologne is not an effective disinfectant or antimicrobial, it can be used to sanitise non-critical items.

Most perfumes contain more than 60% ethyl alcohol, which is a highly potent virucidal and bactericidal agent. This means it is known to be very effective against various common viruses and bacteria. Ethyl alcohol acts as a dehydrating agent and denatures the proteins present in the micro-organisms, destroying their cellular structure.

However, cologne should not be used on open skin, wounds, or mucous membranes as it can cause a severe burning sensation and damage tissues, delaying the healing process. It should also not be used for sterilisation, as certain spores and viruses are immune to ethyl alcohol.

Cologne can be used to sanitise non-critical items such as tabletops, metal, or other external surfaces that come into contact with intact skin. It is important to note that cologne should not be used as a substitute for proper handwashing with soap and water, which is a more effective way to disinfect your hands.

Additionally, the amount of cologne needed to sanitise surfaces may be much higher than the amount of commercial hand sanitiser or disinfectant that would typically be used, making it a less cost-effective solution.

It should not be used on open wounds or skin

While cologne can be used as a disinfectant, it should not be used on open wounds or skin. This is because cologne can cause a severe burning sensation or heat on the wound or area of cut skin. The ethyl alcohol in cologne will damage the tissues on the open wound or skin cuts, which can lead to a delay in the natural healing process.

In addition, cologne is not a good option for sterilisation. While ethanol can kill most germs and microorganisms, certain spores and viruses that cause hepatitis A and polio are immune to ethyl alcohol. Therefore, using cologne or ethanol for sterilisation may not be effective.

It is also important to consider the cost of cologne when using it for disinfection. A good cologne can be expensive, and there is an emotional connection to it as well. An easier and more cost-effective way to disinfect would be to use soap and water.

Furthermore, excessive use of cologne on the skin can lead to skin drying and topical dermatitis. Therefore, it is recommended to avoid using cologne on open wounds or skin and to opt for alternative disinfection methods such as soap and water.

Moreover, cologne should not be used to disinfect clothes or bed linens. The amount of cologne needed to disinfect even a single piece of clothing would be excessive and not cost-effective. Rinsing clothes in water with soap or detergent is a better option for disinfection.

It is not suitable for sterilisation

While cologne can be used as a disinfectant, it is not suitable for sterilisation. This is because certain viruses, such as the polio-virus and hepatitis A virus, are immune to ethyl alcohol, which is the main chemical component in cologne.

In addition, cologne is not suitable for sterilisation because it is not compatible with all surfaces. For example, cologne should not be used to sterilise an object or any medical equipment, as it can damage the surface. It is also not advisable to use cologne on open skin or wounds, as it can cause a severe burning sensation and damage tissues, delaying the natural healing process.

Furthermore, cologne is not a cost-effective method for sterilisation. The amount of cologne needed to disinfect a single item can be excessive, and the emotional connection with a cologne can add to its value. Water and soap are more accessible and affordable alternatives that are just as effective.

Lastly, cologne is not always odourless or fragrance-free, which is a crucial factor in sterilisation to prevent any unwanted reactions or allergies. Fragrances are linked to major health risks such as hormone disruption, neurotoxicity, carcinogenicity, allergies, and asthma.

It is not a cost-effective sanitiser

While cologne can be used as a disinfectant, it is not a cost-effective sanitiser. Firstly, the amount of cologne required to sanitise will be much higher than the amount of hand sanitiser you would typically use. This makes cologne a less economical option.

Secondly, cologne often contains oils, which can leave an oily residue on your hands after use. This means you may need to use additional soap and water to wash off the residue, further increasing the overall cost of using cologne as a sanitiser.

In addition, cologne is not always a safe option for sanitisation. While cologne can kill common germs, certain viruses and bacteria are immune to ethyl alcohol, the main chemical component of cologne. As a result, using cologne as a disinfectant may provide a false sense of security, leading to increased exposure to harmful pathogens.

Furthermore, cologne can be harmful to your health. Fragrances are often linked to major health risks, acting as hormone disruptors, neurotoxins, carcinogens, allergens, and asthma triggers. The presence of undisclosed toxic ingredients in cologne means that you may be exposing yourself to dangerous chemicals with each use, potentially causing more harm than good.

Lastly, cologne is not always practical for sanitising certain items. It should not be used on open wounds or mucous membranes as it can cause tissue damage and delay the healing process. It is also not suitable for sterilising medical equipment as it may not kill all types of viruses and bacteria.

In conclusion, while cologne may have some disinfectant properties due to its high alcohol content, it is not a cost-effective, safe, or practical option for sanitisation. The high cost, potential health risks, and limited effectiveness of cologne make it a less ideal choice compared to other sanitising options such as soap and water or commercial hand sanitiser.

Frequently asked questions