The Scents Of Joan Of Arc's Wardrobe

The life of Joan of Arc, a French historical figure, has been the subject of extensive study and debate. One aspect that has intrigued people is her choice of attire, specifically, whether she wore fragrances. While there is no concrete evidence indicating the specific fragrances she used, we can deduce that she likely wore scents that were common during her time period, such as those derived from natural ingredients like flowers, herbs, and spices.

Joan of Arc, also known as Jeanne d'Arc, lived from around 1412 to 1431 and played a significant role in the Hundred Years' War between England and France. She is known for her cross-dressing, donning male attire, and cutting her hair short. This choice of clothing was controversial and ultimately contributed to her conviction and execution by the English for heresy.

In the absence of specific information about the fragrances she wore, we can only speculate based on the historical context and the availability of fragrances during her lifetime. Natural fragrances were commonly used during the late Middle Ages, and these scents would have been crafted from a variety of ingredients.

Why did Joan of Arc wear men's clothing?

Joan of Arc, the French national heroine and Saint of the Roman Catholic Church, wore men's clothing for a variety of reasons. One of the main reasons was for her protection and safety. As a soldier and knight in the service of the King, she travelled through enemy-occupied territories and accompanied an army of men. She stated that wearing male attire was safer and more appropriate for her in this context.

Joan also wore men's clothing to protect her virginity and prevent sexual assault. She stated that she needed to wear such clothing to protect herself from possible rape, especially when sleeping alongside her male escorts and soldiers. The male clothing, which was tied tightly with cords, served as a safeguard against unwanted advances.

Additionally, Joan's choice of attire was influenced by her belief that she was following the word of God and the directives of her voices. She considered herself a soldier and knight in the service of her King, Jesus, and maintained that she needed to be ready for battle at all times. Wearing men's clothing was practical for riding a warhorse, leading a charge, or climbing a scaling ladder.

It is worth noting that there is some debate surrounding the extent to which Joan wore men's clothing. While some sources claim that she wore it all the time, others suggest that she only donned male attire when necessary and resumed wearing female clothing at other times.

Was it common for women to wear men's clothing in the Middle Ages?

While it is unclear whether Joan of Arc wore fragrance, it is known that she wore men's clothing, which was uncommon for women in the Middle Ages.

In the Middle Ages, clothing served as a means of communication, reflecting one's social status, profession, and personal identity. It was also a way to maintain social order, with sumptuary laws regulating who could wear certain colours and fabrics. While clothing styles varied across different regions and social classes, the basic elements of medieval women's clothing included an undergarment or chemise, an outer garment, and often a headdress.

Women's roles in society during this period were limited, and their clothing choices were influenced by societal expectations of modesty and decorum. While some women worked in fields typically dominated by men, such as trade or medicine, the majority adhered to traditional gender norms and wore clothing that reflected their societal position.

However, there were rare exceptions to this norm, and Joan of Arc was one of them. Joan of Arc, a French national heroine and saint of the Roman Catholic Church, wore men's clothing during her military campaigns in the Hundred Years' War. She adopted this attire for practical reasons, as it provided her with better protection and safety from potential assault. This choice of clothing ultimately contributed to her conviction and execution, as it was considered an abomination by the church clerics.

In conclusion, while it was uncommon for women to wear men's clothing in the Middle Ages, Joan of Arc's unique circumstances and role as a military leader led her to make this unusual choice, which had significant consequences for her life and legacy.

What was the Church's stance on wearing clothes associated with the opposite gender?

The Church's stance on wearing clothes associated with the opposite gender has varied throughout history and has been influenced by social, political, and cultural factors. While the Bible, specifically Deuteronomy 22:5, states that "a woman must not wear men's clothing, nor a man wear women's clothing, for the Lord your God detests anyone who does this", interpretations and exceptions to this rule have emerged over time.

During the early days of Christianity, theologians like Tertullian shamed women who refused to wear their veils in public, considering it a sin against God's natural order and a degradation of femininity. However, as Christianity spread and evolved, the Church's response to cross-dressing became more nuanced and varied across time and region.

In the Middle Ages, the Church's doctrine on cross-dressing combined a general prohibition with exceptions in cases of necessity. The "Summa Theologica" of St. Thomas Aquinas acknowledged that while it was sinful for a person to wear clothing associated with the opposite gender, it could be justified in certain circumstances. Aquinas stated that "it may be done sometimes without sin on account of some necessity, either to hide oneself from enemies, or through lack of other clothes, or for some similar motive." This idea was further supported by other medieval theologians and saints, who recognized the need for cross-dressing in specific situations.

The practice of cross-dressing by female saints out of necessity was a fairly common medieval archetype. For example, St. Margaret donned male attire to escape her wedding night and preserve her virginity. Similarly, Saint Thecla dressed as a man while travelling with Saint Paul. These saints provided a basis for defending the clothing choices of historical figures like Joan of Arc, who wore male soldier's clothing during her military campaigns in the Hundred Years' War.

The Church's response to Joan of Arc's cross-dressing was mixed. Initially, she was accused of abomination by the clerics, and her refusal to wear female clothing was used as a justification for her conviction and execution. However, during her retrial, the charge of cross-dressing was dismissed, as witnesses and theologians argued that her male clothing was necessary for protecting her chastity and safety. This interpretation was supported by figures like Jean Gerson, a famous theologian, who argued that cross-dressing due to necessity did not violate ecclesiastical rules.

In more recent times, the Church's stance has continued to evolve. While some individuals may still view cross-dressing as a sin, others within the Church community have expressed more lenient views, especially when it comes to clothing that is considered gender-neutral or worn for practical reasons. Overall, the Church's stance on wearing clothes associated with the opposite gender has been influenced by a combination of biblical teachings, theological interpretations, and cultural norms, resulting in a varied and evolving response over time.

What was the significance of Joan of Arc's hairstyle?

Joan of Arc's hairstyle was a short, cropped cut, with bangs or a fringe. This was a practical style, similar to the hairstyles popular among men at the time. In fact, Joan of Arc's haircut was so influential that it inspired the bob hairstyle popularised in the early 20th century.

The significance of Joan of Arc's hairstyle can be understood in the context of her cross-dressing. She adopted male clothing and a masculine haircut for her journey to gain an audience with Charles VII at Chinon. This was a practical decision, as she would be travelling through enemy-occupied territory, and her petite frame meant she required men's clothing to be specially made for her.

The practicality of her hairstyle is also reflected in her reasons for wearing men's clothing more generally. She wore men's clothing and armour while accompanying the army, as this was deemed safer and more appropriate than wearing female clothing. She also cited the protection of her virginity as a reason for wearing men's clothing, as it was tied securely to protect her from rape.

The theological debate around Joan of Arc's cross-dressing also sheds light on the significance of her hairstyle. While the clergy prosecuting her argued that her male attire was an abomination to God, her supporters, such as the theologian Jean Gerson, defended her hairstyle, arguing that cross-dressing due to necessity does not violate ecclesiastical rules.

In conclusion, Joan of Arc's hairstyle was significant for both practical and theological reasons. It was a reflection of her adoption of male attire, which was deemed necessary for her safety and protection, and it inspired future fashion trends, demonstrating her enduring influence on culture and style.

What fragrances were used in the Middle Ages?

In the Middle Ages, the use of perfume in Europe took a turn towards herbs and sweet-smelling plants to counter the mustiness of castles and manor houses. The practice of strewing herbs and plants on the floors of wealthy homes became one of the most common ways to improve the atmosphere. Popular fragrant plants for the home included lavender, thyme, meadowsweet, marjoram, germander, and hyssop, all of which were believed to have healing qualities. Rosewater, popularized by crusaders returning from the Levant, was also fashionable among the nobility, and bowls of rosewater were provided for guests to wash and scent their hands after meals.

The Catholic clergy discouraged the use of perfumes or scented oils on the body, but incense was used during mass, and large censers were believed to ward off disease and plague. The censers were the forebears of pomanders, which were used by the nobility to overcome the natural aromas of the urban areas. The pomander, from the French pomme d'ambre, was a small metal case containing a "ball" of perfumed material. The material was a composite of resins such as benzoin, calamite, labdanum, and storax balsam, often shaped into an apple and coated with sweeter spices such as cinnamon, clove, and sweet sanders. Pomanders were also made in the form of skulls, hearts, ships, and books, and smaller versions were carried in the hand or attached to a ring chain.

In the Middle Ages, some fragrances were also used for medicinal purposes. For example, during the Black Death, aromatherapy was used, and doctors and apothecaries created various "anti-plague" preparations, including "four thieves' vinegar", which included rosemary, wormwood, mint, and camphor. Laurel and rosemary were burned in homes to purify the air, as it was believed that bad smells were vectors of disease.

The use of alcohol as a base for perfume was also introduced during the Middle Ages, with apothecaries in Salerno, Italy, using stills and coils to distil alcohol-based perfumes. This led to the creation of Queen of Hungary Water, a formula of alcohol and rosemary that was rubbed on the body to protect against infections and was also ingested.

Frequently asked questions