Heidi Norton
Glossier's cult-favorite fragrance, Glossier You, has undergone a reformulation, according to multiple sources and consumer reviews. The brand confirmed a slight modification to the original formula to comply with regulatory updates, specifically the removal of an unnamed ingredient banned in the EU, UK, and California due to health concerns. While Glossier claims the change shouldn't affect the scent, fans disagree, noting differences in longevity, top notes, and overall muskiness. The new formula has received mixed reviews, with some praising it and others expressing disappointment, particularly regarding the solid perfume's lack of longevity.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Change in formula | The original formula has been modified to comply with regulatory updates. |
| Ingredient removed | Butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial), a synthetic fragrance ingredient, was removed due to bans in the EU, UK, and California. |
| Impact on scent | Some users noticed a stronger alcohol scent and a lack of the signature musky, rich, and animalistic fragrance. |
| Longevity | The new formula may have reduced longevity, with some reporting that the scent doesn't last as long as the original. |
| Top notes and muskiness | Changes in top notes and overall muskiness have been observed, with a reduction in the pink pepper opening and a shift from a warm and cozy scent to a lighter and brighter fragrance. |
| Solid perfume | The solid perfume formula has been criticized for lacking the presence of the scent and not lasting as long as the liquid version. |
| Rollerball | The rollerball formulation is considered closer to the original scent and is more concentrated than expected. |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
The original formula has changed
The original formula of Glossier's perfume has indeed changed. In 2022, Glossier confirmed that the original formula of its cult-favorite fragrance, Glossier You, had been modified. This change sparked discussions among fans, with some expressing disappointment over the reformulation.
The modification was made to comply with regulatory updates within the fragrance industry. Specifically, an ingredient was removed to align with EU regulations while maintaining the signature scent. While Glossier stated that the reformulation shouldn't affect the overall scent, fans across social media disagreed. They noted differences in the lasting power, top notes, and overall "muskiness" of the new formulation.
Some fans observed that the new version lacked the warm and cozy feel of the original, instead leaning towards a lighter and brighter scent. The lasting power of the fragrance was also questioned, with some noticing that the scent didn't linger as long as it used to. The rollerball formulation, however, was noted to be closest to the original scent, offering a more concentrated and long-lasting fragrance experience.
The specific ingredient removed from the original formula was speculated to be butylphenyl methylpropional, also known as lilial. This synthetic fragrance ingredient provided strong projection and longevity to the perfume. However, lilial was banned in the EU, UK, and California due to concerns about skin sensitivity, allergic reactions, and endocrine-disrupting properties.
While the original formula has changed, the new Glossier You still has its fans. Some appreciate the new formulation's unique blend of musk and floral notes with a subtle hint of spice. Despite the reformulation, Glossier You continues to be a popular fragrance, known for its subtle yet long-lasting scent that creates a signature presence.
Make Your Own Patchouli Oil Perfume at Home
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The new formula lacks longevity
In 2022, Glossier confirmed that the original formula for its perfume, Glossier You, had been modified. The brand stated that the change was made to comply with regulatory updates, specifically the removal of an ingredient banned in the EU, the UK, and California due to health concerns. While Glossier claimed that the reformulation would not affect the scent, fans across social media disagreed, noting differences in the lasting power, top notes, and overall "muskiness" of the perfume.
The new formula, according to some users, lacks the longevity of the original. One reviewer noted that the solid formula, in particular, did not seem to last, stating that the scent had disappeared an hour after application. Another reviewer expressed disappointment with the reformulation, noting that the scent no longer had the same lasting power.
The divergence in opinions between the brand and its fans may be due to the subjective nature of scent perception and the interaction between the perfume's ingredients and individual body chemistry. While some people may find that the new formula lasts longer on their skin, others may not have the same experience. It is also possible that the removal of the banned ingredient, speculated to be butylphenyl methylpropional (lilial), impacted the longevity of the scent, as this ingredient was known for giving the perfume strong projection and longevity.
Despite the criticism of the new formula's longevity, some reviewers still expressed a fondness for the new Glossier You. One reviewer recommended the rollerball application method, which they found to be the most concentrated and longest-lasting of the new formulations. Another reviewer, while disappointed with the solid formula's performance, acknowledged that the scent itself was great and that the packaging was adorable and refillable.
Overall, while there is a consensus that the new formula lacks the longevity of the original, some fans still appreciate the new Glossier You for its unique scent and convenient application methods.
Black Orchid Perfume: Who is Behind the Scent?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The banned ingredient, lilial, was removed
In 2022, Glossier confirmed that the formula for its Original Glossier You perfume had been modified. The brand stated that the change was made to comply with regulatory updates and that they had partnered with the original perfumers to remove an ingredient banned by the EU while maintaining the scent. This ingredient was speculated to be butylphenyl methylpropional, or lilial, which was banned in the EU and the UK in 2022 due to concerns about skin sensitivity, allergic reactions, and endocrine-disrupting properties. Lilial was also banned in California in 2023.
The removal of lilial from Glossier You resulted in a divergence between the brand's positioning on the new formulation and fans' perceptions. While Glossier claimed that the reformulation shouldn't affect the overall scent, fans across social media disagreed, noting differences in the lasting power, top notes, and overall "muskiness" of the perfume. The new formulation was described as lighter and brighter, lacking the warmth and coziness of the original.
The change in the Glossier You formula highlights the importance of ingredient awareness in beauty products. Consumers increasingly value transparency and ethical practices, and companies like Glossier, known for its minimalist and cruelty-free positioning, have faced criticism for their lack of transparency regarding ingredients. This discrepancy between brand image and ingredient disclosure can impact consumer trust and confidence in the product.
Despite the controversy surrounding the removal of lilial, some fans still appreciate the new Glossier You. While some prefer the rollerball or liquid formulations for their stronger scent projection, others find the solid perfume, with its balm-like texture, underwhelming in terms of longevity. This variation in experiences underscores the unique interaction between fragrance and individual body chemistry, influencing the scent's evolution and projection over time.
The Art of Fixatives: How Much to Use in Perfume?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The scent is less warm and sultry
In 2022, Glossier confirmed that the original formula for its perfume, Glossier You, had been modified. The brand stated that the change was made to comply with regulatory updates, specifically the removal of an ingredient banned in the EU, the UK, and California due to health concerns. While Glossier claimed that the reformulation shouldn't affect the overall scent, fans and reviewers have expressed mixed reactions and noted differences in the perfume's longevity, top notes, and overall character.
One notable perception is that the scent is now "less warm and sultry" compared to its previous iteration. Before the reformulation, Glossier You was known for its warm, cozy, and creamy scent, with key notes of pink pepper, iris, musk, ambrox, and ambrette. The perfume was praised for its unique, personal scent that adapted to the wearer, creating a signature fragrance that lasted for hours.
However, some reviewers have observed that the new formulation seems to lack the same level of warmth and depth. One reviewer described the new scent as "light and bright," indicating a noticeable shift from the rich and musky character of the original. This change may be attributed to the removal of the banned ingredient, which could have contributed to the warmer and more sultry aspects of the fragrance.
The impact of the reformulation on the scent's longevity has also been a point of discussion. Some users have reported that the new version doesn't seem to last as long on the skin, with one reviewer specifically mentioning that the solid perfume didn't seem to have the same lasting power as the liquid option. This could be related to the removal of the synthetic fragrance ingredient lilial, which was known for providing strong projection and longevity to the perfume.
Despite the disappointment expressed by some die-hard fans, others have found that the new Glossier You still has its merits. Some reviewers continue to appreciate the scent, even if it differs from the original. The rollerball option has been praised for its concentrated formula and long-lasting scent, offering a travel-friendly alternative to the liquid perfume.
Sweet Scents: Cotton Candy Perfumes
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The rollerball smells different from the solid
In 2022, Glossier confirmed that the original Glossier You formula had been modified. The brand stated that the formula for Glossier You had been "slightly modified to comply with regulatory updates, which are commonplace within the fragrance industry." Specifically, an ingredient was removed in compliance with EU regulations, which banned the synthetic fragrance ingredient butylphenyl methylpropional, commonly known as lilial, due to concerns about skin sensitivity, allergic reactions, and endocrine-disrupting properties.
While the perfume and the solid share similar notes, some users have noticed differences in scent concentration and longevity between the rollerball and solid formulations of Glossier You. Some users have reported that the rollerball formulation is more concentrated and long-lasting compared to the solid, which they found to be weaker and less durable. The rollerball formula is described as leaving a noticeable scent trail, while the solid formula, with its alcohol-free and water-free wax base, is said to dissipate more quickly.
However, it is important to note that the perception of fragrance can vary from person to person due to the interaction between perfume ingredients and individual body chemistry. Therefore, the differences in scent concentration and longevity between the rollerball and solid formulations may be influenced by individual factors.
Additionally, some users have expressed a preference for the rollerball formulation, finding it to be a better value option compared to the full-sized perfume bottle and a more durable alternative to the solid, which they found to expire quickly.
While Glossier You has undergone a slight formula change, the brand worked with the original perfumers to maintain the signature scent while complying with regulatory updates. The rollerball and solid formulations may have subtle differences in concentration and longevity, but both are intended to deliver the iconic Glossier You fragrance beloved by fans.
Layering Babycat Over Spicebomb: A Fragrance Guide
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Yes, in 2022, Glossier confirmed that the Original Glossier You formula had been modified slightly.
The formula was changed to comply with regulatory updates, specifically the removal of an ingredient banned in the EU, UK, and California due to concerns about skin sensitivity, allergic reactions, and endocrine disruption.
The exact ingredient removed has not been disclosed by Glossier, but it is speculated to be butylphenyl methylpropional, also known as lilial, a synthetic fragrance ingredient.
Fans have noted differences in the new formula's lasting power, top notes, and overall "muskiness". Some say the scent is less warm and sultry, and now lighter and brighter.
Opinions vary. Some people are disappointed with the reformulation, while others still enjoy the new scent. The rollerball version seems to be the closest to the original formulation and is recommended for those seeking a travel-friendly option.
