Fragrance Ip: Can Scents Be Copyrighted?

The sense of smell is strongly linked to memory, so it's no surprise that fragrances are powerful and that companies would want to protect their unique fragrances from being used by others. However, it is not possible to copyright a fragrance, though there are other ways to protect them. According to European law, perfumes are not protected by copyright because they are not considered art. Instead, legal protection is applied to external elements such as packaging, bottle design, and name. There are other methods of protection, such as patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. Patents can cover the chemical formula of a fragrance but require a detailed description of the formula, exposing companies to the risk of imitation. Trademark registration helps protect company names and logos, while trade secrets protect valuable information that companies want to keep private, such as formulas.

Fragrances can be patented if they meet certain requirements

Fragrances are a man-made composition of matter, and so, in theory, they can be patented. However, this is a complex process and there are several requirements that must be met.

Firstly, the fragrance must be described in detail, including the chemical formula and the process of making it. This means that companies risk exposing their formula to competitors, who could then use it to their advantage. Secondly, the fragrance must be utile, novel, non-obvious, and meet enablement. In other words, it must be new and original, with the creator's personal touch. Thirdly, the fragrance must serve no other important purpose within the product beyond helping a consumer identify the brand. This means that a perfume or candle, for example, could not receive patent protection for its scent because the smell is the primary function of the product.

Given these requirements, many businesses choose to protect their fragrances through alternative methods, such as trademarking or obtaining trade secret protection. Trademark registration helps to protect company names and logos, while trade secrets are valuable pieces of information that a company keeps private so as not to be copied.

Patents last a maximum of 20 years and require detailed descriptions of the formula

While it is possible to patent a fragrance, there are several drawbacks to this approach. According to European law, perfumes are not protected by copyright as they are not considered "art". Instead, they are considered chemicals and are therefore not recognised as creative works. However, it is possible to obtain a patent for a fragrance composition.

This method of protection has its limitations. A patent for a fragrance composition will only last for a maximum of 20 years. To obtain the patent, the formula must be described in detail and then published, exposing the company to the risk of imitation. This is a significant disadvantage, as brands typically value trade secret protection and focus on safeguarding external elements such as packaging, bottle design, and the name of the perfume.

In addition to the short duration and risk of imitation, obtaining a patent for a fragrance composition can be complex and challenging. Fragrances must meet specific requirements to be considered patentable, including being utile, novel, non-obvious, and meeting enablement criteria. They must also be new and non-obvious. This often requires specialised expertise, and even with a patent in place, infringement can be difficult to prove.

As a result of these challenges, many businesses choose alternative methods to protect their fragrances, such as trademarking or obtaining trade secret protection. Trademark registration helps protect company names and logos, while trade secrets involve keeping the manufacturing process and formula confidential and only sharing this information with authorised individuals within the company. While these methods also have their limitations, they are often seen as more feasible and effective options for protecting fragrances in the long term.

Companies can protect fragrances through trademarks

While it is not possible to copyright a fragrance, companies can protect their perfumes and colognes through trademarks. Trademark registration helps to protect company names and logos. If a company receives a trademark, they can protect the name of their fragrance and the logo that identifies it. This means that others would be legally prohibited from using a name or logo similar to theirs, which could cause confusion for customers.

To register a trademark, companies must submit a trademark application to the trademark office. This application should include branding materials, relevant images, and a detailed description of the fragrance itself. To be approved for a trademark, companies may also have to show that their consumers know that their fragrance is part of their brand, often referred to as secondary meaning. Logos or names that have registered trademarks may use the trademark symbol next to them, showing the public that it is protected.

There are several requirements for a scent to qualify for a trademark. Firstly, the smell must be something that a consumer identifies as part of the brand's product or service, differentiating that particular brand from others with similar products. Secondly, a company should offer proof that the scent is not functional by definition. This means that the fragrance must not serve an important purpose within the product other than to help a consumer better identify the brand. For example, perfumes or candles cannot receive trademark protection for their scent because the smell they give off is the purpose or function of the product.

Despite the ambiguous standards for scent trademarks, companies are increasingly keen on safeguarding appealing fragrances frequently linked to their products. Some companies that have successfully trademarked their unique scents include Verizon (flower scent), Flip Flop Shops (coconut smell), Manhattan Oil (fuel fragrances), and Hasbro (Play-Doh smell).

Olfactory trademarks are a recent development in the EU

However, recent developments in EU law and advancements in odour recognition technology have opened up new possibilities for olfactory branding. The EU's reform of trade marks, including the Trade Marks Directive and the European Union Trade Mark (EUTM) Regulation, have removed the requirement for graphic representation. Now, olfactory marks can be represented in other ways, such as through chemical formulas, descriptions, and samples.

The new legislation defines a trademark as any sign that can distinguish the goods or services of one undertaking from another. This includes words, designs, letters, colours, shapes, and sounds. Olfactory marks fall under this definition, as scents can convey information and be distinctive if they are not an inherent characteristic of the product.

To be registered as a trademark in the EU, an olfactory mark must be represented clearly, precisely, and objectively. It must also be easily accessible, durable, and self-contained. These criteria are known as the Sieckmann criteria, named after the aforementioned case. While meeting these criteria is challenging, advancements in technology may make it easier. Techniques such as gas chromatography and smelling screens may enable more accurate and accessible representation of olfactory marks.

The EU's reform of olfactory trademarks has potential benefits and drawbacks. Businesses may welcome the opportunity to innovate their branding strategies, while others may worry about the commodification and monopolisation of scents. The success of olfactory trademark registration will depend on the accuracy and commercialisation of odour recognition technologies, as well as legal and technical innovations.

Trade secrets are another way to protect fragrances

While it is not possible to copyright a perfume, there are alternative ways to protect fragrances. Trade secrets are one such way. Trade secrets are valuable pieces of information that a company keeps private so that others cannot copy them. For instance, Coca-Cola is known for its longstanding trade secrets, which protect the recipe for its soda.

To be considered a trade secret, the manufacturing process and formula must be kept confidential and only shared among select authorised individuals within the company who need to know. For example, at Coca-Cola, those combining the ingredients would know the quantities required, but those selling the product would not.

There are several steps you can take to demonstrate that you have kept your fragrance information confidential, including:

• Limiting access to the formula and requiring those with access to sign binding non-disclosure agreements (NDAs).
• Implementing strict policies and procedures to ensure only authorised individuals have access to the formula.
• Labelling all related documents and materials with "trade secret" or "confidential".
• Restricting access to where the fragrance is made or stored.

While trade secrets can be useful, they do not offer the same legal protections as trademarks or patents. Trade secrets do not prevent others from creating similar products through reverse engineering. Therefore, some companies may choose to have a patent or trademark in addition to a trade secret.

Frequently asked questions