Colognes: Antiseptic Qualities And Uses

The use of cologne as an antiseptic has been a topic of discussion, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. While some sources claim that cologne can be used as a disinfectant due to its high alcohol content, others argue that it is not effective. Turkish kolonya, for example, has been used as an antiseptic and hand sanitiser due to its high alcohol content, which can kill germs and viruses. On the other hand, some experts warn that cologne is not intended to be used as a disinfectant and may not be effective in killing microorganisms. They recommend using commercial hand sanitisers or proper handwashing with soap and water as more reliable methods for maintaining hygiene and preventing the spread of diseases.

Turkish kolonya is an antiseptic with a high alcohol content

Turkish kolonya is a traditional, aromatic fragrance that has been synonymous with Turkish hospitality and health since the Ottoman Empire. It is often described as Turkey's national scent and is usually made with fig blossoms, jasmine, rose or citrus ingredients. Kolonya is also an antiseptic with a high alcohol content—most products contain 80% alcohol.

Kolonya has been used in Turkey for hundreds of years and is traditionally sprinkled on guests' hands as they enter homes, hotels and hospitals, or to finish meals at restaurants. However, its high alcohol content also means it can kill more than 80% of germs, acting as an effective hand disinfectant.

During the coronavirus pandemic, sales of kolonya soared as people in Turkey turned to this traditional fragrance as a way to protect themselves against the virus. Turkey's Minister of Health championed kolonya's capacity to fight coronavirus, causing a surge in demand for the product.

The production of kolonya is a relatively simple process. Pure ethanol is made from fermented barley, grapes, molasses or potatoes and is mixed with distilled water. A natural fragrance is then added—common options include magnolia, lemon or rosemary—and the mixture is left to sit for a three-week maturation period before being bottled.

Kolonya is not only used for its antiseptic properties but is also believed to have other health benefits. For example, sprinkling a few drops onto a sugar cube is said to aid digestion, and rubbing it onto your temples can relieve a headache.

Commercial hand sanitizers are more effective than cologne

While cologne can be used as an antiseptic, commercial hand sanitizers are a more effective option.

Firstly, it is important to note that cologne is not an effective disinfectant or antimicrobial. While cologne often contains more than 60% alcohol, which is effective in killing common forms of bacteria, it is not a replacement for hand sanitizer. This is because the alcohol in cologne is not sufficient to kill microorganisms, as it does not remain in contact with the skin for long enough due to its quick evaporation.

On the other hand, commercial hand sanitizers contain between 60-70% alcohol, which is the recommended amount by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This concentration of alcohol is effective in killing microorganisms by creating holes in their cell walls, allowing water to enter and cause lysis.

Additionally, cologne is not designed to be used on the skin in the same way as hand sanitizer. It often contains oils and other additives that may irritate the skin or leave an unpleasant residue. Cologne may also be more expensive to use than hand sanitizer, as a larger amount is required for the same level of disinfection.

Furthermore, cologne should not be used on open wounds or mucous membranes, as the alcohol can damage tissues and delay healing. It is also not suitable for sterilizing medical equipment, as certain viruses and spores are immune to ethyl alcohol.

In conclusion, while cologne may have some disinfectant properties due to its alcohol content, commercial hand sanitizers are a more effective, safe, and cost-efficient option for hand hygiene. They are designed specifically for this purpose, with the correct concentration of alcohol and added ingredients like aloe vera gel, which enhance their effectiveness and prevent skin irritation.

Cologne is not an effective disinfectant

While cologne contains alcohol, which is a key ingredient in hand sanitizers, it is not an effective disinfectant. This is because the alcohol content in cologne is not high enough to act as a disinfectant. Commercial hand sanitizers contain between 60-70% alcohol, while perfumes and colognes range from 70-97% alcohol. However, the higher concentration of alcohol in cologne means that the alcohol will evaporate quickly, so contact time is not sufficient for disinfection.

Furthermore, cologne is not intended to be used as a disinfectant. Fragrance oils are not meant to be used in leave-on products in large quantities, and certain oils and aromachemicals are restricted in their use in perfumes. Using cologne as a disinfectant may lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions, or the oils may cause photo-sensitisation.

In addition, the scent of cologne may be overpowering if used as a disinfectant, and it may not be practical for frequent use. While cologne may have some disinfectant properties due to its alcohol content, it is not as effective as a commercial hand sanitizer or regular hand-washing with soap and water.

Therefore, while cologne may have some antiseptic properties due to its alcohol content, it is not a suitable replacement for commercial disinfectants or proper hand hygiene practices.

Cologne is not an effective antimicrobial

While cologne contains alcohol, a key ingredient in hand sanitizers, it is not an effective antimicrobial or disinfectant. Commercial hand sanitizers contain between 60-70% alcohol, while perfumes and colognes range from 70-97% alcohol. However, the alcohol in cologne evaporates quickly, meaning it does not have sufficient contact time to kill microorganisms effectively.

Additionally, cologne does not contain water or water-containing ingredients, which are necessary for the process of cell lysis. Without water, the alcohol may cause the outermost cell proteins to coagulate and "seal" the cell, preventing the water from entering and killing the cell.

Furthermore, cologne is not intended to be used as a leave-on product in large quantities and may cause skin irritation or allergic reactions. The fragrance oils in cologne are restricted in their use, and over-application may lead to skin issues or photo-sensitisation.

Therefore, while cologne may have some antimicrobial properties due to its high alcohol content, it is not as effective as commercial hand sanitizers or regular hand-washing with soap and water. It is important to use cologne only for its intended purpose as a fragrance cosmetic and not as a substitute for proper hand hygiene or disinfecting practices.

Cologne is not an effective replacement for hand sanitizer

While cologne does contain alcohol, a key ingredient in hand sanitizers, it is not an effective replacement for hand sanitizer.

Firstly, cologne is not designed to be used as a hand sanitizer. It is a cosmetic product meant to be dabbed or sprayed on pulse points and left to evaporate. When used as a hand sanitizer, it is rubbed into the hands in larger amounts, which can lead to skin irritation or allergic reactions. The fragrance oils in cologne are not intended to be used in leave-on products in large quantities, and certain oils and aromachemicals are restricted in their use in perfumes.

Secondly, the scent of cologne can be overpowering when used as a hand sanitizer. This can be unpleasant and may limit how often you are willing to use it.

Thirdly, cologne may not contain a high enough percentage of alcohol to be effective against viruses and bacteria. Commercial hand sanitizers contain between 60-70% alcohol, while perfumes range from 70-97% alcohol. If the alcohol content is too low, it may evaporate before it has had time to kill infectious agents.

Finally, even properly made commercial hand sanitizers are much less effective than regular hand-washing with soap and water. Hand sanitizers should only be used as a temporary measure when soap and water are not available.

In conclusion, while cologne may have some antiseptic properties due to its alcohol content, it is not a suitable replacement for hand sanitizer. It is important to use products as intended and follow public health guidelines to effectively reduce the spread of infectious diseases.

Frequently asked questions