Orthodox Jews And Cologne: What's The Verdict?

In Orthodox Judaism, the use of perfume is considered feminine and sensual. While it is acceptable for women to wear perfume in public for their own enjoyment, it should be done in a way that only they or other women can enjoy it. For men, wearing cologne is often considered inappropriate, effeminate, and unmanly. However, since many men commonly wear cologne today, it is not considered strictly forbidden. In certain communities, a man wearing cologne may be seen as a lack of modesty or a display of pampering.

Wearing cologne is considered a lack of modesty

In Orthodox Judaism, wearing cologne is considered a lack of modesty. While Jewish law does not explicitly prohibit men from wearing cologne, it is generally seen as inappropriate and effeminate. The concept of "simlas isha", which refers to something typically worn by women, is often cited as a reason for men to avoid wearing cologne.

The use of perfume or cologne is considered feminine and sensual in Jewish culture. For women, wearing perfume is acceptable for personal enjoyment or to attract a potential spouse during a shidduch date. However, it is considered inappropriate for a woman to wear perfume outside the home if it can be detected by men, as it may be seen as immodest and attention-seeking.

Some Orthodox Jews view wearing cologne as an inappropriate display of pampering and a lack of modesty. This perspective suggests that men should avoid wearing cologne to prevent attracting attention or being perceived as trying to impress others.

Additionally, the Talmud in Nazir 59 provides insight into the matter. It states that it is a Rabbinic prohibition for a man to shave his body hair, as it is typically associated with women. By extension, wearing cologne, which is commonly associated with women, could be interpreted as a similar breach of modesty.

However, it is important to note that the acceptability of wearing cologne may vary depending on the community. In communities where it is customary for men to wear cologne, it may not be seen as a breach of modesty. Nonetheless, within the specific context of Orthodox Judaism, wearing cologne is generally viewed as a lack of modesty, especially when worn to attract attention or for sensual purposes.

It is seen as a feminine act, akin to cross-dressing

In Orthodox Judaism, the use of perfume is considered feminine and sensual. Wearing perfume is seen as a way to attract a partner and is therefore only permitted in private between a husband and wife. However, if worn for personal enjoyment, it is acceptable for women to wear perfume in public as long as it is subtle and only noticeable to those in close proximity.

Since Judaism considers the act of wearing perfume to be feminine, when a man wears cologne, it is related to the Torah prohibition of cross-dressing. Although it is not considered strictly forbidden, it is still seen as inappropriate, effeminate, and "unmanly". In a community where it is common for men to wear cologne, there is no prohibition. However, in a community where men typically do not wear cologne, it may be seen as more unacceptable.

The discussion of wearing cologne or perfume is particularly relevant to perfumes, which are designed to disseminate an appealing and attractive scent. On the other hand, deodorants, which are meant to prevent or mask unpleasant odours, are generally permitted for all to use in all contexts.

Some people argue that wearing cologne or perfume is not a problem as long as it is worn in moderation and is only noticeable to those in close proximity. However, others argue that even a subtle scent can be noticed by strangers and is therefore still considered attention-grabbing and inappropriate.

Overall, while there is no strict prohibition against men wearing cologne in Orthodox Judaism, it is generally seen as inappropriate due to its association with femininity and sensuality.

It is inappropriate and unmanly

In Orthodox Judaism, the use of perfume in its many forms is considered feminine and sensual. This means that it is deemed appropriate only when it is either permitted to be sensuous or in non-sensuous situations. Since Judaism considers the act of perfuming oneself to be feminine, a man wearing perfume is associated with the Torah prohibition of "cross-dressing".

Although modern norms have changed, with many men wearing cologne, it is still considered inappropriate, effeminate, and "unmanly" for a man to wear cologne, even if it is solely for his personal enjoyment. This perception aligns with the broader view that men's perfume is inappropriate and should be avoided by those who follow Orthodox Jewish customs and traditions.

The idea that men's cologne is inappropriate in Orthodox Jewish culture stems from the belief that it is a form of pampering or a lack of modesty, which are not typically associated with traditional masculine ideals. Additionally, it may be seen as a form of "simlas isha", something worn by women, and thus not suitable for men. These cultural norms and religious interpretations shape the perspective that men's cologne is inappropriate and unmanly within the context of Orthodox Judaism.

However, it is worth noting that the interpretation of Jewish law on this matter is not uniform. Some argue that since wearing cologne is a common practice among men in modern society, there should be no prohibition against it, especially when considering the principle of "Kavod HaBriyos" (respecting people). This perspective suggests that wearing cologne can be acceptable as long as it is done in a subtle and respectful manner.

In conclusion, while the use of cologne by men may be deemed inappropriate and unmanly by some followers of Orthodox Judaism, others may interpret the religious laws differently, allowing for a more flexible approach to this matter. Ultimately, the decision to wear cologne or not is a personal choice influenced by one's interpretation of religious teachings, cultural norms, and personal values.

It is acceptable in private, for the pleasure of a spouse

In Orthodox Judaism, the use of perfume and cologne is considered feminine and sensual. For this reason, it is deemed acceptable only when it is either permitted to be sensuous, or in situations that are not sensuous.

For women, wearing perfume in public for the purpose of attraction is prohibited. However, if a woman wears perfume for her own pleasure, it is considered acceptable in public, as long as only she or other women can enjoy it. In such cases, she may also wear it in the presence of close male family members, such as fathers, brothers, and sons. Single women can also wear perfume in public, as long as it is not to attract men.

An exception for a single woman to wear perfume in the presence of a man is on a shidduch date. In this context, a man and a woman meet with the intention of attracting and being attracted to their potential future spouse.

While wearing cologne is not considered strictly forbidden for men, it is generally frowned upon as inappropriate, effeminate, and "unmanly." However, if a man wears cologne with the intention to attract a woman inappropriately, it would be forbidden for reasons of immodesty. Therefore, it would only be acceptable for a man to wear cologne if his wife enjoys it, and only in private.

It is important to note that these guidelines specifically refer to perfumes and colognes, which are designed to disseminate appealing and attractive scents. Deodorants, on the other hand, are intended to prevent or mask unpleasant odors and are permitted for use by all, regardless of gender or situation.

It is acceptable to wear cologne in a tight-knit community where it is common for men to do so

In a tight-knit community where it is common for men to wear cologne, it is acceptable for Orthodox Jewish men to wear cologne. This is because, as Rabbi Yosef Friedman explains, "if it is a place where it is common for men to [engage in a practice], it is not prohibited." In this case, the practice in question is wearing cologne.

However, it is worth noting that the perspective on wearing cologne differs depending on the community. In communities where men do not commonly wear cologne, the logic of "if it is a place where it is common for men to [engage in a practice], it is not prohibited" no longer applies. Therefore, in such communities, it may be considered inappropriate or even prohibited for Orthodox Jewish men to wear cologne.

The perspective on cologne for men in Orthodox Jewish communities is influenced by the association of perfume with femininity and sensuality. Rabbi Yirmiyahu Ullman explains that "the use of 'perfume' in its many forms is considered simultaneously feminine and sensual." This perspective leads to the belief that men wearing cologne is related to the Torah prohibition of "cross-dressing." However, Rabbi Ullman also acknowledges that since many men today wear cologne, it is not strictly forbidden as cross-dressing. Nevertheless, it is still considered inappropriate and "unmanly" for men to wear cologne, even if it is for their own personal enjoyment.

The acceptability of wearing cologne in Orthodox Jewish communities also depends on the intention behind it. If a man wears cologne with sensual intentions to attract someone when it is inappropriate to do so, it would be forbidden for reasons of immodesty. In such cases, wearing cologne would only be considered appropriate if it is for the pleasure of his wife and worn in private.

Additionally, the manner in which cologne is worn also plays a role in its acceptability. As discussed in a forum on The Yeshiva World, cologne should be worn in moderation, without overwhelming others with a strong scent. It is considered inappropriate for cologne to be noticeable to everyone in the vicinity. Instead, it should only be noticeable to someone who comes very close to the wearer.

In summary, while the acceptability of wearing cologne for Orthodox Jewish men depends on various factors, including community norms, intentions, and manner of use, it is generally acceptable in tight-knit communities where it is common for men to wear cologne.

Frequently asked questions