Fragrance-Free Hospitals: A Comfortable And Safe Environment

Fragrances are a mixture of thousands of chemicals intended to produce a particular scent. They are used in thousands of consumer products, including perfumes, soap, cleaning products, air fresheners, and personal care products. Many health-care facilities around the world are becoming fragrance-free. Fragrances can be detrimental to the health of workers with chemical sensitivities, allergies, asthma, and chronic headaches/migraines. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has been following a fragrance-free policy as part of its Indoor Environmental Quality Policy since 2009. Hospitals should be a secure shelter for people who are ill, and the hospital environment should accommodate all patients regardless of their specific illness.

Hospitals should be fragrance-free to protect patients with asthma, chemical sensitivities, and allergies

In fact, about 30% of people report having some sensitivity to scents worn by others, and 27% of people with asthma say their disease is made worse by such exposures. There is also evidence that suggests that asthma, in some cases, is primarily aggravated by artificial scents. This is particularly concerning in hospitals, where vulnerable patients with asthma or other upper airway or skin sensitivities are concentrated. These patients may be involuntarily exposed to artificial scents from staff, other patients, and visitors, resulting in a worsening of their clinical condition.

Hospitals should be a safe space for patients, free from potential triggers that could cause harm. By implementing a fragrance-free policy, hospitals can reduce the risk of exposing patients to harmful chemicals and help protect their health and well-being. This includes not only artificial scents but also scented cleaning products and air fresheners, which can contain toxic ingredients and contribute to poor indoor air quality.

Additionally, federal and provincial human rights acts require accommodation for employees who are sensitive to scents in the workplace. Hospitals should extend this accommodation to their patients, who may not have a choice or warning when exposed to fragrances and suffer social isolation as a result.

Overall, hospitals have a responsibility to prioritize the health and safety of their patients above all else. By adopting fragrance-free policies, hospitals can create a safer and more inclusive environment for patients with asthma, chemical sensitivities, and allergies.

Fragrances are made from thousands of chemicals, many of which are toxic and have harmful health effects

Fragrances are made from a combination of natural and synthetic ingredients, with the latter being derived from petroleum. There are over 3,500 fragrance chemicals in use today, and these are often grouped under umbrella terms such as "fragrance" or "perfume" on product labels. While the specific chemicals used in fragrances vary, common ones include limonene, linalool, geraniol, and eugenol, which are known to cause a range of health issues.

Fragrances and their formula constituents are considered volatile organic compounds (VOCs). This means that vulnerable populations are exposed to these chemicals daily, and they can trigger various acute and chronic health conditions due to repetitive human exposure. The negative health impacts of fragrance chemicals include cutaneous, respiratory, and systemic effects such as headaches, asthma attacks, breathing difficulties, cardiovascular and neurological problems, skin allergies, and distress in workplaces.

Fragrances are widely used in personal care and household products, including cosmetics, deodorants, air fresheners, disinfectants, laundry detergents, and candles. The use of fragrances in these products is often to create a pleasant aroma or to mask unpleasant odors. However, the benefits of fragrances should be weighed against their potential health risks, especially for sensitive individuals.

To reduce potential exposure to harmful fragrance chemicals, it is recommended to read the full list of ingredients on product labels and opt for products that are fragrance-free or bear safety verification marks. Additionally, consulting databases that provide ratings for personal care products and their ingredients can help identify products that are less likely to contain fragrance chemicals.

Fragrances are one of the most prevalent indoor air pollutants, and indoor air quality is often more polluted than outdoor air

The use of fragrances in hospitals is a controversial topic. While some people argue that fragrances should be avoided in hospitals due to the potential health risks for patients and staff, others believe that fragrances can provide benefits in a healthcare setting. Some patients and visitors appreciate fragrances in hospitals as they can create a clean, hygienic, and welcoming environment, reduce stress and anxiety levels, and promote a sense of wellness and recovery. Additionally, certain fragrances like lavender, peppermint, and eucalyptus have been shown to have analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects, while citrus and peppermint scents can help reduce nausea and vomiting.

However, the potential benefits of fragrances in hospitals need to be carefully weighed against the risks. Fragrances can trigger allergic reactions, respiratory distress, and even severe asthma attacks in susceptible individuals. It is important to prioritize the health and safety of patients, especially those with known sensitivities or respiratory conditions.

To balance these concerns, hospitals can implement policies that minimize the use of strong fragrances while still maintaining a pleasant environment. This may include encouraging staff and visitors to use fragrances sparingly, choosing fragrances that are less likely to trigger sensitivities, or designating fragrance-free zones in certain areas of the hospital.

Ultimately, the well-being of patients should be the top priority in hospitals. While fragrances can provide some benefits, the potential risks associated with indoor air pollution and scent sensitivity cannot be ignored. Hospitals should strive to create a safe and comfortable environment for all patients, staff, and visitors.

Fragrances can cause serious symptoms in patients, including nausea, migraines, asthma attacks, and anaphylaxis

Fragrances can cause a range of adverse reactions in patients, with some individuals being more sensitive than others. One of the most common symptoms is nausea. Strong scents can overwhelm the sense of smell, leading to feelings of nausea and discomfort. This heightened sense of smell is known as hyperosmia, which can be temporary or a symptom of an underlying condition. It is often associated with pregnancy and can also occur during migraine episodes.

Fragrances can also trigger asthma attacks, especially in individuals with pre-existing asthma or respiratory issues. Certain chemicals found in artificial fragrances, such as aerosol body sprays and perfumes, can act as irritants and trigger asthma symptoms. These include petrochemicals, alcohols, coal, and coal tar. Inhaling these substances can cause the airways to constrict and produce mucus, making it difficult to breathe.

In rare cases, fragrances can also cause anaphylaxis, a severe and potentially life-threatening allergic reaction. Anaphylaxis involves difficulty swallowing, a rapid or weak pulse, and other allergic symptoms. It requires immediate medical attention.

Additionally, fragrances can induce migraines and headaches. The chemicals in fragrances can irritate the sinuses and activate the trigeminal pathway, a nerve pathway that transmits sensory signals to the brain. This irritation and stimulation can lead to inflammation and headache pain.

To prevent these adverse reactions, hospitals should adopt fragrance-free policies. This includes staff, patients, and visitors refraining from wearing strong perfumes, colognes, or other scented products. It is essential to prioritize the safety and well-being of vulnerable patients by minimizing their exposure to potential triggers.

Fragrance-free policies are becoming more common in healthcare facilities, with support from organisations like the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)

In addition to the CDC, many hospitals and healthcare facilities in Canada and other countries are also implementing fragrance-free policies. These policies ask patients, visitors, healthcare professionals, and staff members to refrain from using any fragranced products, including deodorants, hairsprays, perfumes, and cleaning products. This is due to the growing awareness of the adverse health effects of fragrances, which can trigger or exacerbate conditions such as asthma, migraines, allergies, and chemical sensitivities.

Establishing fragrance-free environments is already well-established in several Canadian provinces, and hospitals are taking the lead in promoting these policies to ensure the safety and well-being of patients, staff, and visitors. Fragrance-free policies in healthcare facilities are important to accommodate sick and vulnerable populations, as well as protect the health of healthcare workers themselves.

While some may argue that fragrances provide a pleasant distraction from the antiseptic smell of hospitals, the potential harm caused by fragrances to vulnerable individuals cannot be ignored. Fragrances are mixtures of thousands of chemicals, with up to 4,000 ingredients used in manufacturing, and 95% of these ingredients are petroleum-based volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that easily disperse into the air. This can have serious health consequences, especially for those with chemical sensitivities or respiratory issues.

Therefore, the growing trend towards fragrance-free policies in healthcare facilities, supported by organisations like the CDC, is a positive step towards creating healthier and more inclusive environments for patients, staff, and visitors.

Frequently asked questions