Fragrance Allergens: Are They Safe To Use?

Fragrances are a common ingredient in many cosmetic products, and their smell is often a deciding factor in whether we choose to buy them. However, fragrances can contain allergens that may cause skin irritation or allergic reactions in sensitive individuals. These reactions can range from itchy, red rashes to more severe symptoms like anaphylaxis. While fragrance allergens are not dangerous for non-allergic individuals, they can pose a significant health risk to those with allergies. The fragrance industry has been criticised for keeping fragrance ingredients secret, making it difficult for those with allergies to identify and avoid certain products. To address this, regulations have been put in place to require the labelling of certain recognised allergens in cosmetic products.

What are fragrance allergens?

Fragrance allergens are substances that can cause an allergic reaction in sensitive individuals. They are often found in fragrant ingredients such as essential oils, perfumes, and cosmetics. These allergens are regulated to limit the risk of contact allergies for consumers, with strict rules on concentrations and packaging mentions.

Fragrance allergens can be derived from natural sources or chemical synthesis. They are organic compounds with a characteristic, usually pleasant smell. They are commonly found in perfumes and perfumed consumer goods such as cosmetics, detergents, fabric softeners, and other household products. Fragrances provide consumers with a desired fresh smell or mask unpleasant odours.

The most common problems associated with fragrance ingredients are skin allergies and skin irritations. Many people complain about intolerance or rashes after using perfumes or fragranced products. However, most complaints described as 'skin rashes' are believed to be irritant reactions rather than skin allergies. A key difference is that allergic reactions typically occur with a delay of about one day after using the product, while irritant reactions develop immediately.

To cause a skin allergy, a certain minimum amount of the fragrance substance must penetrate the skin and attach to a skin protein. Once an allergy has developed, it is a lifelong condition. Symptoms include redness, swelling, and vesicles commonly described as a 'skin rash', which may occur upon re-exposure to the fragrance allergen.

The risks associated with fragrance allergens include irritation and allergies, such as redness and itching, for individuals sensitive to these substances. However, these risks are quite limited, and mentioning these ingredients on packaging is more for informational purposes rather than health concerns. The goal is to facilitate the detection of allergens for individuals susceptible to allergic reactions.

The European Union has identified and regulated a list of fragrance allergens, with the Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) playing a key role in evaluating and identifying fragrance allergens. The SCCS recommended that consumers be made aware of the presence of all known and likely fragrance allergens in cosmetic products, not just the initially listed 26 allergens. As of 2023, the EU has expanded the number of recognised allergenic substances to 81.

How do fragrance allergens affect the body?

Fragrance allergens can affect the body in a variety of ways, and it's important to distinguish between an allergy and a sensitivity. When someone has a fragrance allergy, their body's immune system identifies the ingredient in the perfume as a foreign substance and releases an inflammatory reaction to fight it off. This immune response usually takes a few days to develop and manifests as itchiness or a rash that can last for weeks. In contrast, fragrance sensitivity is much more common and is a reaction to something that irritates the body without necessarily triggering a full immune response.

The symptoms of a fragrance allergy can range from mild to severe. Mild symptoms include itching (sometimes without any visible rash or irritation), itching around the eyes and throat, dry and scaly skin, blisters, patchy red skin, and increased sensitivity to sunlight. More severe symptoms that may require immediate medical attention include swelling in the mouth, lips, or tongue, and anaphylaxis, which is a life-threatening allergic reaction characterized by inflammation of the airways and difficulty breathing.

Fragrance allergens can also affect the respiratory system, especially for individuals with asthma, allergic rhinitis, or viral respiratory infections. Inhaling fragrances can result in shortness of breath, a sensation of suffocation, coughing, phlegm, a runny or stuffy nose, headaches, chest tightness, and wheezing.

It's worth noting that most ingredients in perfumes that cause reactions are not allergens but rather synthetic or chemical irritants. Allergens are technically proteins that trigger an inflammatory response from the body.

How can you test for fragrance allergies?

To test for a fragrance allergy, you should first consult a doctor, allergist, or dermatologist. They will be able to examine your skin and determine whether your rash is due to an allergic reaction. If you have a history of outbreaks, they may be able to diagnose a fragrance allergy by discussing your past experiences and the personal care products you used before the reaction.

To definitively determine whether your reaction is caused by fragrance compounds, you will need to undergo skin patch testing. This involves placing patches with allergens attached onto your skin for 48 hours. The skin is then evaluated after 48 hours, and again 72-96 hours later for delayed hypersensitivity reactions. If standard patch tests are negative, extended patch testing with a broader panel of individual allergens can be carried out.

In addition to patch testing, a skin prick test can be used to diagnose perfume allergies. This involves pricking the skin with a tiny amount of the suspected allergen and observing any reaction.

How are fragrance allergens regulated?

The regulation of fragrance allergens is a complex and evolving area. Here is an overview of the key points:

Identification of Fragrance Allergens

The identification of fragrance allergens is a critical aspect of their regulation. Fragrance allergens are substances naturally present in fragrant ingredients (essential oils, etc.) or the ingredients themselves, which can cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals. The Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) plays a critical role in identifying these allergens. In 2012, the SCCS released its scientific opinion on fragrance allergens, finding that 16% of eczema patients were sensitized to ingredients found in fragrances, and 1-3% of Europeans showed allergic reactions to common fragrance ingredients.

Labelling Requirements

The labelling of products containing fragrance allergens is a key regulatory measure. The European Union's Cosmetic Regulation states that any of the 26 allergens mentioned in Annex III should be listed in the ingredients if specific concentration thresholds are exceeded: 0.001% for leave-on products and 0.01% for rinse-off products. This regulation was updated in 2023, expanding the recognized allergenic substances to 81. The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) also provides guidelines for safe use and concentration limits for fragrances.

Restrictions and Bans

In addition to labelling requirements, certain fragrance allergens are restricted or banned in cosmetic products. For example, Annex II of the European Union's regulation prohibits over 1300 different substances in cosmetic goods. Lyral, atranol, and chloroatranol were added to this list in 2019 due to their potential to cause allergies. The SCCS has also recommended against the use of Evernia prunastri (oak moss) and Evernia furfuracea (tree moss) extracts due to their content of strong sensitizers.

Global Exposure Considerations

Fragrance allergens can be found not only in cosmetic products but also in other consumer goods, pharmaceuticals, and occupational settings. The SCCS has identified several routes of exposure, including direct skin contact, inhalation, and secondary exposure from another individual. Certain anatomical sites, such as the axillae, face, and hands, are more vulnerable to fragrance allergen exposure and subsequent allergic reactions.

Dose-Response Relationships and Thresholds

The dose-response relationship between exposure to fragrance allergens and the induction of allergy is well established. The SCCS and the fragrance industry have developed models to determine safe exposure thresholds, taking into account factors such as the number of exposures and the accumulated dose. These models aim to protect consumers from allergic contact dermatitis and prevent further cases of sensitization.

Elicitation Thresholds

Elicitation thresholds refer to the dose of a fragrance allergen that can trigger an allergic reaction in sensitized individuals. These thresholds vary depending on the specific allergen and the type of product. For example, deodorants and perfumes are associated with axillary dermatitis, as the axillary skin is particularly vulnerable to sensitization due to occlusion, maceration, and irritation.

In summary, the regulation of fragrance allergens involves identifying allergens, implementing labelling requirements, restricting or banning certain substances, considering global exposure routes, and establishing safe exposure thresholds and elicitation thresholds to protect consumers from allergic reactions.

What are the risks of fragrance allergens?

Fragrance allergens pose a risk of irritation or allergic reaction to sensitive individuals. These reactions can include redness, itching, rashes, and swelling. In rare cases, severe allergic reactions can lead to anaphylaxis, which can be life-threatening. Fragrances are a common cause of allergic reactions, with almost 20% of the general population being sensitized to at least one allergen.

The risks associated with fragrance allergens are not universal; they only affect individuals with specific sensitivities. However, the exact substances that can cause these reactions are not always disclosed on product labels or websites, making it challenging for those with allergies to avoid them. This lack of transparency has significant health implications and costs for affected individuals, who often have no choice but to avoid all fragranced products.

To address this issue, regulations have been implemented to ensure the disclosure of fragrance allergens. For example, the European Union's Cosmetic Regulation states that any of the 26 allergens mentioned in Annex III should be listed in the ingredients if specific concentration thresholds are exceeded. The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) also provides guidelines for safe fragrance use, including maximum concentration recommendations for different product categories.

It is worth noting that fragrance allergens are not considered "dangerous" in the same way as ingredients known to be carcinogenic. Instead, they pose a risk primarily to individuals with specific sensitivities.

Frequently asked questions